Crewman ‘possibly affected by alcohol’ when he died

An investigation has found a crewman who died on board a cargo ship at Townsville in 2008 may have been affected by alcohol.

The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) has completed its final report into a fatal incident on the Maltese-registered container ship ‘Spirit of Esperance’.

In November 2008, a crewman died after falling four metres while trying to stow a cargo crane hook while the ship was berthed in Townsville.

The investigation found that the correct procedures were not followed during the docking of the ship and raised concerns about whether safety procedures were routinely met.

It also found that the crewman was probably under the influence of alcohol at the time of the accident which may have affected his reaction time, balance and general ability.

Oil pumped from grounded coal ship

Salvagers have pumped almost 40 tonnes of oil from a coal carrier grounded on the Great Barrier Reef off central Queensland.

It has been almost a week since the Shen Neng ran aground on Douglas Shoal, spilling more than two tonnes of oil.

Authorities are now pumping out more than 970 tonnes of fuel oil still on the ship.

Queensland Premier Anna Bligh says the ship’s insurer will be forced to pay for the salvage operation and the Government will recoup its expenses from the insurance company.

“But that is a matter for down the track,” she said.

“Number one priority – get this ship out of this reef safely without any damage to the reef.”

Ms Bligh says the shipping company could face fines of up to a million dollars over the incident.

Reporting dispute

Australian maritime authorities are disputing a claim that the grounding was reported within five minutes.

In a statement on Friday the Chinese state-owned Shenzhen Energy Transport apologised for the incident saying it is cooperating with authorities.

The company says it alerted Australian authorities about five minutes after the ship ran aground but the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) disputes the claim, saying it was not told for about an-hour-and-a-half.

It then took another 25 minutes for Maritime Safety Queensland to become involved.

AMSA has asked the Chinese company to clarify its comments.

There was criticism last year that authorities took too long to act after a major oil spill off south-east Queensland.

Could take days

Meanwhile, authorities are putting safety equipment in place to reduce the risk of a further spill as they prepare to pump out the remaining fuel.

About 250 workers are on standby should any oil reach the coast.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) general manager Patrick Quirk says it could take days to transfer all the oil.

“This is just a part of a long process and we need to keep our eye on the short game, which is the pumping of the oil,” he said.

“The medium-term game is the refloating and what we’re going to do when we refloat her.”

Mr Quirk says the carrier is holding together.

“The salvors have put on electronic monitoring, hull-monitoring equipment and they have advised that they are detecting no further deflections of the hull, which means that the damage has stabilised,” he said.

“We’re doing a metre-by-metre check of the ship with the salvors and that will determine what goes into the computer programs in terms of the damage-assessment reports.”

Mr Quirk says the weather conditions today are favourable.

“A bit of a wind change due Monday which we’ll need to keep our eye on, but at the moment we’re not being alarmed by the weather change,” he said.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says the oil transfer is a difficult and delicate operation.

“Anyone who thinks this is all over red rover, frankly, they’re not getting it right,” he said.

“This is going to take a lot of time, a lot of technical precision and hard work and it’s a very difficult situation still with no absolute guarantee of success.”

Political ‘sightseeing’

Meanwhile, Queensland Opposition Leader John-Paul Langbroek has criticised Premier Anna Bligh for travelling to inspect the stricken coal carrier.

Ms Bligh will today fly over the ship.

Mr Langbroek say Ms Bligh is the fourth Labor politician to go and look at the damage.

“I think it’s interesting that Anna Bligh is following the example of Kevin Rudd, [Federal Environment Minister] Peter Garrett and [Queensland Transport Minister] Rachel Nolan to be the fourth senior politician to take a plane flight over the Shen Neng 1,” he said.

“I think it’s time for the sightseeing to stop by senior politicians and let’s just let the experts get on with fixing it.”

- Reporting by Paul Robinson, Maria Hatzakis, Kerrin Binnie and Natalie Poyhonen

Questions about ‘delay’ in reporting ship’s grounding

Australian maritime authorities are disputing a claim that a coal ship grounding off central Queensland was reported within five minutes.

The Shen Neng 1 ran aground on Douglas Shoal just after 5pm (AEST) last Saturday afternoon.

In a statement today the Chinese state-owned Shenzhen Energy Transport apologised for the incident saying it is cooperating with authorities.

The company says it alerted Australian authorities about five minutes after the ship ran aground but the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) disputes the claim, saying it was not told for about an-hour-and-a-half.

It then took another 25 minutes for Maritime Safety Queensland to become involved.

AMSA has asked the Chinese company to “clarify” it’s comments.

There was criticism last year that authorities took too long to act after a major oil spill off south-east Queensland.

Salvage operation

Meanwhile, authorities are starting to pump oil from the stricken coal carrier.

They are putting safety equipment in place to reduce the risk of a further spill as they prepare to pump out the remaining fuel.

About 250 workers are on standby should any oil reach the coast.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) general manager Patrick Quirk says it could take days to transfer all the oil.

“This is just a part of a long process and we need to keep our eye on the short game, which is the pumping of the oil,” he said.

“The medium-term game is the refloating and what we’re going to do when we refloat her.”

Mr Quirk says the carrier is holding together.

“The salvors have put on electronic monitoring, hull-monitoring equipment and they have advised that they are detecting no further deflections of the hull, which means that the damage has stabilised,” he said.

“We’re doing a metre-by-metre check of the ship with the salvors and that’ll determine what goes into the computer programs in terms of the damage assessment reports.”

Mr Quirk says the weather conditions today are favourable.

“A bit of a wind change due Monday which we’ll need to keep our eye on, but at the moment we’re not being alarmed by the weather change,” he said.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says the oil transfer is a difficult and delicate operation.

“Anyone who thinks this is all over, red rover frankly, they’re not getting it right,” he said.

“This is going to take a lot of time, a lot of technical precision and hard work and it’s a very difficult situation still with no absolute guarantee of success.”

Political ‘sightseeing’

Meanwhile, Queensland Opposition Leader John-Paul Langbroek has criticised Premier Anna Bligh for travelling to inspect the stricken coal carrier.

Ms Bligh will today fly over the ship.

Mr Langbroek say Ms Bligh is the fourth Labor politician to go and look at the damage.

“I think it’s interesting that Anna Bligh is following the example of Kevin Rudd, [Federal Environment Minister] Peter Garrett and [Queensland Transport Minister] Rachel Nolan to be the fourth senior politician to take a plane flight over the Shen Neng 1,” he said.

“I think it’s time for the sightseeing to stop by senior politicians and let’s just let the experts get on with fixing it.”

- Reporting by Paul Robinson, Maria Hatzakis, Kerrin Binnie and Natalie Poyhonen

Federal police asked to probe coal ship oil spill

Australian Federal Police (AFP) have been called in to investigate how a bulk coal ship ran aground on the Great Barrier Reef off central Queensland.

Salvage crews are today expected to start pumping fuel oil off the Shen Neng 1, which ploughed at full speed into Douglas Shoal, east of Rockhampton, last Saturday.

The Chinese-registered ship ruptured a fuel tank and damaged the engine room when it ran aground.

Several tonnes of fuel oil leaked into the ocean but that has been dispersed with chemicals.

About 975 tonnes of oil remain on the stranded ship.

Two response boats are at the site and have inflated booms around the coal carrier to minimise any further spillage.

Around 250 people are on standby in case oil reaches the coast but that is now considered unlikely.

The AFP has been asked to consider mounting a criminal investigation into how the ship ran aground but has not yet confirmed whether it will investigate.

Maritime authorities are already looking into the incident.

Salvage begins

Authorities will today start pumping the remaining oil supply off the ship ahead of attempts to refloat the vessel.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) spokesman Patrick Quirk says recovery ships are in place to prepare for the pumping operation.

“The bunker barge Larcom and our salvage response vessels managing the boom are in position,” he said.

“The processes are taking place to get the oil moving but as yet they are not pumping any oil.

“It is an involved process to connect the pumps and the hoses and our check lists satisfied.

“We’ll start the process when we’re happy that it’s safe to do so.”

Premier Anna Bligh will also fly over the stricken ship today.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, Federal Environment Minister Peter Garrett, Greens Leader Bob Brown and Queensland Transport Minister Rachel Nolan have already flown over Douglas Shoal this week.

It is still not clear when authorities will try to move the ship off the reef.

RSPCA spokesman Michael Beatty says it is looking for volunteers to head to central Queensland should there be a major oil spill.

Mr Beatty says it is only a contingency plan.

“Particularly wildlife carers or people who have experience with wildlife is to go on to our website and register on there – obviously with contact numbers, details of experience and availability – and then we can mobilise those people basically instantly to go up and assist if needed,” he said.

Meanwhile, a maritime law expert doubts the Queensland Government will recover the full cost of salvaging the ship.

The State Government says the ship’s owners will be forced to pay for the full clean-up and salvage costs.

But maritime expert Professor Nick Gaskell has told AM that there is a cap on the amount they will have to pay and there is likely to be a gap between the actual cost and what the owners will have to pay.

“There is a maximum amount calculated according to the size of the ship, and my calculations on the information available to me indicate that the maximum sum for this ship will be in the region of $23.5 million,” he said.

“In exchange for having a no-fault liability, the ship owners are entitled to have a ceiling, a maximum amount of damages for which they’re liable.”

Credit crunch still impacting port

The Port of Portland is still feeling the pinch of the global financial crisis.

Chief executive Scott Paterson says exports are down about 15 per cent because it exports to countries that have not recovered from the crisis.

Mr Paterson says it is also waiting for some of its exporters, like the Alcoa aluminium smelter, to return to previous production levels.

“One big trade that has come off and remains off, that’s the smelter,” he said.

“They cut production last year by 15 per cent [and] they haven’t gone back and reintroduced that extra volume, so that’s down.

“Globally the demand for their product is still soft.”

Charity sinks ferry purchase plan

The Sale Rotary Club has decided not to buy a paddleboat from Ballarat after receiving a marine surveyor’s report.

The club was considering buying the Begonia Princess ferry to operate from the port of Sale.

But spokesman Alan Lewis says the boat has been grounded since 2002 and regulations to register boats with the marine board have changed since then.

“Regulations with respect to survey of boats have changed and there was some doubt expressed whether – even if we did refurbish it – we could in fact get it back into survey,” he said.

“In light of that we considered it inappropriate to proceed.”

Shires urged to settle Oakajee stoush

Nationals’ MP Grant Woodhams has urged two warring mid-west Western Australian shires to sit down and sort through their differences.

The Geraldton Greenough Council is pushing to take over part of the Shire of Chapman Valley so the site for the proposed Oakajee deep-water port falls into its local government boundaries.

The move comes weeks after Chapman Valley backed out of a merger with Geraldton Greenough and the neighbouring Shire of Mullewa.

The Member for Moore says even though from a political perspective he represents the Shire of Chapman Valley, he has always been happy to represent Geraldton as well.

“I would hope that sort of philosophy if you like could also be translated across to the City of Geraldton Greenough and the Shire of Chapman Valley, that they might be prepared to sit down and discuss things, particularly in this instance related to the future of Oakajee,” he said.

Mr Woodhams admits he was surprised to learn of the city of Geraldton Greenough’s plans.

“This latest proposal by the council to take over the Oakajee precinct, to take it away from the Shire of Chapman Valley, isn’t something which they had discussed with me, so at the moment I only have representations from the Shire of Chapman Valley and as I say they’re in my electorate and that’s who I represent,” he said.

Meanwhile, the Western Australian Conservation Council says no-one can guarantee uranium will not be shipped through Oakajee Port, until the State Government details the port’s business case.

Premier Colin Barnett yesterday dismissed claims by the proponents behind the Oakajee project, that the mid-west port might be used in the future to ship yellow cake.

Mr Barnett says because of the economics involved in uranium mining, it would not make sense to export the material through Oakajee.

But the Conservation council’s mining spokesman, Tim Nichol, says he is not convinced by the Premier’s comments.

“The conservation council has been calling for a public inquiry into uranium and greater transparency around the business case for Oakajee Port, so until those reports are undertaken and released we can’t have any greater confidence at all that the Oakajee Port won’t be used for uranium,” he said.

Ports forum tackles green issues

Environmental officers from ports across Australia are meeting in Albany today to take part in an industry forum.

More than 40 port representatives will participate in talks about the impact of dredging and emissions on marine life and the environment.

Ports Australia executive officer Susan Fryda says environmental issues are the main concern of ports today.

She says it is a good opportunity to share tactics and information.

“We’re also talking about issues to do with ballast water and introduced marine pests, making sure that we have better practices around our ports to facilitate the impacts that could happen, so it’s very much a communal, positive, sharing information experience,” Ms Fryda said.

Harbour environmental studies to be revealed

The Port Kembla Port Corporation will release the environmental studies for the outer harbour expansion tomorrow.

The plans include seven new berths with associated container and multipurpose terminals, supported by enhanced road and rail infrastructure.

Seventy-two hectares will be filled in with coal wash, slag and other materials collected from Sydney tunnelling projects.

The corporation’s chief executive officer, Dom Figliomeni, says only inert materials will be used below the waterline.

“So coal wash won’t actually be mixed with seawater,” he said.

“It forms a fairly stable platform above the high water mark, so as such all of the studies that have been done have shown that is a stable platform and doesn’t compromise the environment at all.”

Meanwhile, the corporation has announced Wollongong businesswoman and public relations consultant Janine Cullen as a new board member.

Ms Cullen says it is an exciting time to be involved with the port as it undergoes a period of major growth and development.

She says she was appointed to the position by a Government Minister.

“It’s a position that hopefully the Government thinks about long and hard,” Ms Cullen said.

“It’s recommended by a Minister, then it goes to three ministers, the Treasurer gets the final call to put it up to Cabinet, then Cabinet puts it up to the Governor.”

The study results will be on public display for six weeks from tomorrow.

CEO report indicates solid industry recovery

A poll of Australian chief executives shows growth in the country’s manufacturing, construction and services sectors is expected to be reasonably solid, but uneven in 2010.

The result is contained in the latest CEO survey, Industry in Recovery Mode in 2010, conducted by the Australian Industry Group and Deloitte.

An improvement was expected across all three industries, with particular strength in the services and manufacturing sectors.

The survey also found improving consumer confidence in incomes growth and employment prospects, as well as rising household wealth and exposure to strong growth in China, would drive growth this year.

But the fading effects of the Federal Government’s stimulus and the impact of higher interest rates were likely to hit the construction sector particularly hard.

On average, manufacturers were anticipating a 5.6 per cent increase in the nominal value of sales in 2010 to about $415 billion.

Sales in the services sector were set to rise 6.6 per cent and construction sales were forecast to grow by 2.5 per cent.

Employment in the manufacturing industry was expected to rise 2.9 per cent, service sector employment was due to increase by 2.3 per cent, and the construction sector was set for employment growth of just 0.5 per cent.

Those employers surveyed said the possible re-emergence of skills shortages was a real worry, as the economy returns to growth.

The chief executive of the Australian Industry Group, Heather Ridout says the economy looks set to consolidate this year, but the rebound won’t be as strong as those that occurred after previous downturns.

“Despite the stronger sales and employment expectations, investment trends across these sectors remain soft and conservative,” she said.

“The challenges for policy and for business will be to strengthen the recovery while addressing the ongoing requirement to build on the foundations of longer-term growth.”

The manufacturing partner for Deloitte, Damon Cantwell says 2010 would provide businesses with a range of opportunities to make up ground.

“While 2009 was characterised as a year founded on survival, 2010 offers real opportunities for growth,” he said.

Ports still closed in wake of cyclone Ului

Coal terminals in north Queensland remain closed after ex-Tropical Cyclone Ului dumped more than 350 millimetres of rain on the region.

North Queensland Bulk Ports staff are inspecting the Dalrymple Bay terminal, south of Mackay, and the Abbot Point terminal near Bowen, south of Townsville, but no major damage has been reported.

Mining company BMA says operations at its South Walker Creek mine near Nebo in the state’s Central Highlands region will resume tomorrow.

The chief executive of North Queensland Bulk Ports, Brad Fish, says they do not know yet when the ports will reopen.

“The harbour masters will make the decisions on reopening the ports and we’d expect that to happen over the next day or so,” he said.

“It’s not critical though because the shipping has left the port anyway at the present time, so it’ll be a day or two before shipping is back in port.”

Oakajee documents ‘will make deadline’

The proponents of the Oakajee port and rail project in WA’s Mid West say they are on track to deliver crucial project documents to the State Government.

Oakajee Port and Rail (OPR) must submit a draft bank feasibility study and construction agreements to the Government by March 31.

OPR’s chief executive, John Langoulant, says it has been a busy 12 months for the project team but he is confident the documents will be with the Government before the deadline.

“We’ll be doing that if not on the 31st, just prior to it,” he said.

“We’ve been in close dialogue with the Government about those documents and they’re very happy with the progress that’s being made.”

Mr Langoulant says the draft feasibility study should provide the Government with a reasonable indication of the progress so far.

“They give the picture to the Government of exactly how this project is going to look, how it’s going to be located, how it’s going to be constructed,” he said.

“Towards the end of the year, we’ll then have all of the information we need from both the miners and further engineering work on how we can then go ahead and get this project banked.”

Questions asked about diverted cruise ship

Speculation is continuing that an un-dredged sandbar caused a cruise ship to divert to an unscheduled New South Wales Far South Coast port.

The Dutch liner, Volendam, was supposed to have docked at Batemans Bay earlier this week with 1500 crew and passengers, but it moored at Eden instead.

Authorities said the decision was made due to operational problems.

Pambula Beach resident, Les Sullivan, says passengers he spoke to were told that a sandbar at the mouth of the Clyde River was too shallow for ship tenders to make it to port at Batemans Bay.

But he says the tourists were not worried about the change.

“They seemed very casual and light hearted about it all,” he said.

“As one said, it is better than endless castles and cathedrals.

“We sat down and chatted to some of them for up to half an hour, and they were just delighted to have a relaxing day onshore.”

For more, go to the South East News blog at http://bit.ly/dgL1SN

Fishing boat scuppered on Moreton Bay

A former fishing boat that will form part of an artificial reef in Moreton Bay in south-east Queensland has been sunk two days earlier than planned.

The ‘Tiwi Pearl’ was supposed to be flooded near St Helena Island on Sunday morning.

Instead, it was moved five kilometres to its planned position and scuppered on Friday afternoon to make an artificial reef for fishing.

Minister for Climate Change and Sustainability Kate Jones says it was the safest option.

“Once it had broken two of its four moorings, the decision was made that it was taking water, and the safest and best option was to take it to its new home at Harry Atkinson Reef,” she said.

“This is something that the recreational fishing industry wanted,” she said.

“We agreed to deliver six artificial reefs across Moreton Bay and the sinking of the Tiwi Pearl will be the first of those.”

Port plan promises jobs boost

The North West Iron Ore Alliance says Pilbara communities are set to benefit from a proposed port project in Port Hedland after the results of a pre-feasibility study.

The alliance says the study shows the proposed port could see 50 million tonnes of iron ore exported a year from South West Creek and be operational by 2013.

The proposed port, estimated to cost just over $2 billion, will provide shipping services for Atlas Iron, Brockman Resources and FerrAus.

Alliance chief executive Tony Considine says the proposed port would not be just a win for industry.

“I think it has very positive news for the community in the sense that it would generate $200 million a year of expected royalties, create something like 600 jobs in the local community during construction and about 50 jobs once it’s in operation,” Mr Considine said.

Onus on shipbuilders in downturn

Australia’s Export Finance and Insurance Corporation says it will support Australian shipbuilders during an industry downturn, if builders find credit-worthy clients.

Shipbuilders say hundreds of millions in export dollars are at risk because the strengthening Australian dollar is pushing buyers to consider more competitive overseas suppliers.

Two major Australian shipbuilders, Tasmanian-based Incat and West Australian shipbuilder AUSTAL, have called on the finance corporation to ease its lending terms.

But the corporation’s executive director, Peter Field, says the organisation needs to consider the risks of all applications carefully.

“There is certainly potential buyers for both producers at the moment but we have to look at those buyers in terms of the credit risk we would be assuming if we were to fund them.”

Mr Field says AUSTAL’s call to lower its interest rate can not be met because EFIC is a statuatory corporation that can meet but not compete with banks on interest rates.