Australian police investigate Google over privacy issues

Australian police have been asked to investigate internet giant Google over possible breaches of telecommunications privacy laws, Attorney General Robert McClelland said on Sunday.

The investigation follows complaints from members of the public about activities of Google employees while taking photographs for Google Maps, the search engine’s maps page. It comes amid a wave of criticism over the use of personal information by the internet giants.

The matter was referred to the Australian Federal Police on Friday after complaints from members of the public, McClelland told journalists in Melbourne at the start of a forum on internet security.

“On Friday the attorney-general’s department did refer those allegations and those reports to the Australian Federal Police,” McClelland said.

“They relate in substantial part to possible breaches of the Telecommunications Interceptions Act, which prevents people accessing electronic communications other than for authorised purposes.”

A police spokeswoman confirmed a referral had been received.

A Google spokesman in Australia could not be immediately contacted for comment on Sunday. (Editing by Sugita Katyal)

Community group hopes to create mid-north NSW legal centre

An advocacy group will apply for funding for a Community Legal Centre pilot program on the New South Wales mid-north coast

Community Legal Centres provide help and advice for people who are disadvantaged or struggling financially.

Catherine Peek from Disability Advocacy NSW says there are no centres between Newcastle and Lismore.

Ms Peek met with the Federal Attorney-General Robert McClelland in Port Macquarie to discuss how to get a centre for the mid-north coast.

“It was a really positive meeting,” she said.

“He’s made some suggestions to the group and one of those suggestions was to apply to his department for a small amount of pilot project funding.

“Hopefully we’ll be able to set up a pilot in the area over the next couple of years to get something off the ground.

Ms Peek says she thinks there is a huge need for a community legal centre in the region.

“We’ve got an ageing population, a high Indigenous population and more and more migrants and refugees,” she said.

” I think all of those groups would great benefit in having a centre where they knew that they could get free and accessible legal advice for any issue.”

Australia police hunt accused Serb commander

Thu, Apr 1 11:26 AM

A former Serb commander accused of war crimes in the Balkans was being hunted by Australian police on Thursday after disappearing in the wake of a court ruling that he could be extradited to Croatia.

Dragan Vasiljkovic, 55, an Australian who also has Serbian citizenship, lost a four-year legal battle on Tuesday when Australia’s High Court approved his extradition and reinstated a 2006 warrant for his arrest.

Croatia holds Vasiljkovic, whose Australian name is Daniel Snedden, responsible for torturing and killing Croat soldiers and civilians, as well as a foreign journalist, when he commanded a Serb paramilitary unit during Croatia’s 1991-95 independence war.

“Mr Snedden is now required to be committed to prison to await the Minister for Home Affairs’ final determination whether or not to surrender him to Croatia to face prosecution for war crimes offences,” a spokeswoman for Australia’s Attorney-General Robert McClelland said.

Vasiljkovic, known as “Captain Dragan” during the war in Croatia, won an earlier appeal against extradition when a lower court found he had grounds for believing he could be punished or imprisoned because of his nationality or political opinions.

Last week, the presidents of Croatia and Serbia promised a new era in relations, effectively resuming ties after a year of silent hostility.

On Wednesday, Serbia’s parliament apologised for the 1995 killing of thousands of Bosnian Muslims in the eastern enclave of Srebrenica, the worst atrocity in Europe since World War Two.

Police were on Thursday searching Vasiljkovic’s last known residence in the town of Boambee, north of Sydney. Vasiljkovic did not attend the court and police had no power to arrest him until after the High Court ruling.

Australia’s Home Affairs Minister Brendan O’Connor and McClelland will have the last say on whether Vasiljkovic will be extradited to Croatia.

Croatia declared independence from communist Yugoslavia in 1991, but its Serb minority, backed by Belgrade, rebelled and seized a third of the country by force. Croatia crushed the rebellion in two offensives in 1995.

(Editing by Raju Gopalakrishnan)

Police hunt for accused war criminal

Federal Police are trying to locate an Australian man wanted in Croatia for alleged war crimes.

A High Court decision yesterday paved the way for the Federal Government to extradite Dragan Vasiljkovic, also known as Daniel Snedden, to Croatia.

He is accused of torturing and murdering civilians and prisoners of war.

A spokeswoman for Federal Attorney-General Robert McClelland says Mr Snedden did not attend the High Court ruling and has not notified authorities of any change to his address.

She says a police search is underway to find him.

The Federal Court had earlier allowed Snedden’s appeal against extradition, ruling his political beliefs would mean he would be dealt with unfairly in Croatia.

But the High Court quashed that decision, allowing the Federal Government to now consider whether to extradite him.

Last year a Sydney court heard allegations of repeated rape and abuse at the hands of Snedden, known as Captain Dragan at the time, during the Balkans conflict of 1992.

Snedden sued publishers Nationwide News Limited over a story printed in 2005.

A jury found the story had a number of defamatory meanings, including that he condoned the rape of women.

The Supreme Court judge ruled in favour of the publisher who had argued a truth defence.

‘Captain Dragan’ faces extradition for war crimes trial

The High Court has paved the way for an Australian man to be sent to Croatia to face war crimes allegations.

Australia received a request in 2006 for Dragan Vasiljkovic, also known as Daniel Snedden, to be extradited to Croatia.

The Federal Court allowed Snedden’s appeal against extradition, ruling his political beliefs would mean he would be dealt with unfairly in Croatia.

The High Court has quashed that decision, allowing the Federal Government to now consider whether to extradite Snedden.

Last year, a Sydney court heard allegations of repeated rape and abuse at the hands of Snedden, known as Captain Dragan at the time, who is accused of war crimes during the Balkans conflict of 1992.

Snedden sued publishers Nationwide News Limited over a story printed in 2005.

A jury found the story had a number of defamatory meanings, including that he condoned the rape of women.

The Supreme Court judge ruled in favour of the publisher who had argued a truth defence.

The Department of Federal Attorney-General Robert McClelland says Snedden must now be held in custody pending a decision on his extradition by the Minister for Home Affairs.

A spokeswoman for the Attorney-General’s Department says the Australian Federal Police are trying to locate Snedden.

New Chief Justice of Federal Court sworn in

Justice Patrick Keane has been sworn in as the new Chief Justice of Australia’s Federal Court.

The ceremony took place this morning at a special sitting in Brisbane.

Justice Keane says his new role is to keep the court “on course”.

“It’s a good court, it’s an efficient court, it’s an important court, it’s a happy court and if when I finish I can say that, I’ll be very happy,” he said.

Federal Attorney-General Robert McClelland says Justice Keane is well-equipped for the task.

“Extraordinary intellect, great achievement at the bar and also a decent man and that’s very important to keep the collegiate nature and culture of the court,” he said.

“I think he’s a down-to-earth man, and a man of good humour and he’ll be a tremendous leader for the court.”

Peter Eardley from the Queensland Law Society (QLS) praised the appointment of the first Queenslander to take on the position.

“We are very confident that your learning, your diligence your humanity will allow you to be a beacon in judicial decision making throughout Australia,” he said.

The Chief Justice was also complimented for his wit – illustrated by his first decision in his new role.

“I decline to record a conviction against any of you for outrageous flattery in a public place,” he said.

Chief Justice Keane will administer the Federal Court from Brisbane.

Government tinkers with sedition law

Federal Attorney-General Robert McClelland has introduced a range of amendments to Australia’s counter-terrorism laws, including one that renames the offence of sedition.

The changes also include giving police new powers to enter a place without a warrant if there is material that is a risk to public safety.

Mr McClelland says it is already an offence to urge force or violence against a group on the basis of race, religion, nationality or political opinion, if those actions would threaten national peace.

“The offence will also be expanded so that it applies to the urging of force or violence against an individual, not just a group,” he said.

“It covers the urging of force or violence even where the use of the force or violence does not threaten the peace, order and good government of the Commonwealth,” he said.

He says the changes help ensure the right balance in national security.

“The Government is confident that this package of reforms delivers strong laws that protect our safety whilst preserving the democratic rights that protect our freedoms,” he said.

“[It] helps prepare us for the complex national security challenges of the future.”

Australians caught in Ethiopian adoption nightmare

Australian families have made serious allegations of corruption within Australia’s inter-country adoption program with Ethiopia.

The ABC has spoken to several families who claim they have been lied to in the course of their adoption process.

They have told heartbreaking stories of their time in Ethiopia – from witnessing their new baby choking on vomit, to a young boy being kept in a bucket to stop him from moving about. One family had to pay a bribe and others found their paperwork falsified with their child’s age dramatically altered.

The families say the Federal Government has been slow to act and has not fully investigated the allegations.

When Jody was holding her baby son in her arms, she was distraught to witness an Ethiopian mother discover she had lost hers forever.

“When I was walking [out of the women's centre] a lady screamed and yelled and cried and fell to the ground,” she said.

“This mother had come back to the women’s shelter [where] she’d placed her baby for adoption. She changed her mind and came back to get it within a couple of days – but it was already gone.

“That was just heart-wrenching and I felt sick.”

She added that she thought the process was far too quick to have gone through the proper channels.

Last year Foreign Correspondent revealed corruption within US-Ethiopia adoptions, and more families have spoken out as a result.

It seems some Australians are not protected from corruption despite it being an Australian Government-run program.

The person in charge of the program is Ato Lakew Gebeyehu. ABC News Online made a number of attempts to contact Mr Gebeyehu, but was unable to do so.

Mr Gebeyehu is responsible for Koala House, a transition home for children going to be adopted by Australian families. This home, which is part of the Australian government program, is accused of not properly feeding the children and maintaining their health.

The office of Attorney-General Robert McClelland says a recent review found issues of concern within the program and is working to restructure the program.

ABC News Online has been told by a spokesman for Mr McClelland that Australia will sign a new agreement with Ethiopia, however whether Mr Gebeyehu remains in his position is still to be decided.

But the ABC has obtained documents showing the Howard government knew of serious concerns about the program in 2005 and that the Rudd government was warned again in 2008 by Brussels-based human rights organisation Against Child Trafficking.

Koala House

The families interviewed by the ABC have had their names changed because of fears they may lose their children and concerns that life will be made hard for surviving biological relatives in Ethiopia.

Australian parents pay thousands of dollars in fees, donations and aid for the care of their children in Koala House.

But all three families say their children were handed to them with a range of problems including severe malnutrition and pneumonia.

Sarah, who has adopted three Ethiopian children, believes the money she paid to care for her children never reached them.

“In our first adoption we took over about 80 kilos of aid. The majority of that was formula, and because we had a baby we also paid the formula fee for her,” she said.

“We were also asked to replace all of the formula she would have consumed during her time she was at Koala House … and it turned out she was actually fed cow’s milk and was lactose intolerant.

“She was massively malnourished when we got her. She had full-blown pneumonia because she’d been swallowing her own vomit.”

Sarah’s older daughter later explained that she was hardly fed.

“She’d get given rice and carrot mixed together as a meal of porridge for breakfast. Except for when the Australian families came … [they] would put on a big party … and when that happened, there would be so much food. But when those families went, then it’d be carrot and rice,” she said.

Jody says it was a similar story when she and her husband were in Ethiopia to collect their son from Koala House.

“Our son has attachment issues, but he was never held or cuddled until we got him. He was just picked up to be changed or had a bottle propped up on a pillow,” she said.

“We were told when we picked him up that they used to sit him in a bucket so he couldn’t learn to move around much. He’d worn all the hair off the back of his head from it rubbing against the bucket.

“A friend of ours had an older child who says they only get one meal a day, which was concerning because the amount of money that we raised for the centre. I raised thousands and thousands.”

Program reinstated

Earlier this month Mr McClelland announced he will lift a temporary suspension of the adoption program, after concerns of possible breaches of the Hague Convention on inter-country adoption.

The convention is in place to ensure the welfare of children is the priority and that international adoptions are used only as a last resort. Australia is a signatory to the convention but Ethiopia is not.

It will resume operating on April 6 with some changes made, but it appears Mr Gebeyehu will stay in charge.

Against Child Trafficking spokeswoman Roelie Post says Mr Gebeyehu was arrested in Ethiopia and held for 12 days on suspicion of trafficking children to Austria in 2008.

Ms Post says her organisation received little response from the Australian Government after alerting it to this and other alleged concerning practices.

“The children are not orphans. The paperwork is often faked. Parents are declared dead who are not dead and children are given the wrong ages,” she said.

“Our organisation sent a letter to the Australian Government with 1,600 pages attached to it with evidence of trafficking in adoptions relating to Australia and India.

“Also we alerted the Australian authorities to Ethiopia, especially to the Ethiopian representative whose name was mentioned in a trafficking case in Austria.”

Ms Post does not accept the Australian Government’s explanation that Mr Gebeyehu’s arrest was just a case of mistaken identity. She thinks there are serious issues that need to be investigated and that the case was mishandled.

“The children come from the same pool, therefore the situation [in Australia] is comparable to adoptions in the US or the Netherlands or any other country.”

Sarah says she is aware of older adoptive children recognising each other from Ethiopia and while she stops short of calling it child trafficking, she says it is “on the fringes”.

“I have heard that has happened in Australia, where children have known each other prior to coming under Lakew’s care – that’s a very big coincidence,” she said.

Blocked

All families interviewed by the ABC claim they were not supplied with paperwork and vital information about their children and were blocked by officials from finding information on biological families.

When Anne and her husband adopted their daughter, they say almost all the information about their child’s origin was falsified.

They were told she was abandoned, but when through their own search they tracked down the biological parents, they discovered this was a lie.

“The [birth parents] were both devastated, particularly the father. They were so sad to think that their child would have grown up thinking she had been abandoned by them.

“They told us that they could never have done such a thing to their child. They agonised over the decision to relinquish their daughter and they did it legitimately.

“What makes us angry is that our daughter was stripped of her history and there seems to be no valid reason for this to have happened.

“Our child was given a new name and a new birth date and was passed off as having been abandoned.”

Sarah adopted two sisters in 2002. She and her husband were told the “orphaned” children were four years old and nine months, with no living relatives.

They later found the eldest daughter was not four, but closer to eight. They also discovered the girls had a mother and that the eldest had two brothers whom she was allegedly warned never to mention.

“She told us exactly where they were and we located them two days later and the brothers told us at the time that she was eight years old,” she said.

Jody was also told that her son was abandoned and there was no information about his mother. But years later when her family returned to Ethiopia for their second adoption, they discovered this was not the case.

“With a bit of what we call African persuasion, which is $500, we managed to get a photograph, full name and full details of his birth mother,” she said.

“The whole place revolves around money under the table.”

Peace-making sheikh on verge of deportation

Religious and community leaders in Sydney are rallying behind an Iranian sheikh who will be deported from Australia in a fortnight.

Sheikh Mansour Leghaei has lived in Australia for the past 16 years but was prevented from gaining a permanent visa after being declared a security threat by intelligence agency ASIO.

The sheikh’s supporters say he is a peace maker and has been building bridges between Islam and Christianity for more than a decade.

Even Federal Attorney-General Robert McClelland wrote a character reference supporting the sheikh in 1997 when Mr McClelland was a member of the opposition.

But after years of battling ASIO and immigration officials in the courts, Sheikh Leghaei will be sent back to Iran.

His wife and one of his three sons will also be deported.

His supporters from an inter-faith religious council are furious that ASIO has refused to re-consider its negative security assessments of the sheikh.

Reverend David Smith from Sydney’s Holy Trinity Anglican Church says authorities know he is not a serious threat.

“They made a negative security assessment of him, 13 years ago, and they’ve known about him for 13 years,” he said.

“How seriously do they take his threat? They know he’s not a serious threat.”

Another supporter, Professor Alan Coates, says he does not want to lose someone who encourages inter-faith dialogue.

“Communications between the faiths is always a delicate flower,” he said.

“Dr Leghaei has been a very good gardener and we don’t want to lose him.

“If we lose him his own community will suffer.

“Hundreds of people are attached to his community, and under whose influence they might fall next we don’t know.”

Justice ‘denied’

Two weeks ago the Migration Review Tribunal denied the sheikh a visa after ruling it lacked the authority to examine or overrule ASIO’s assessment.

ASIO is not obliged to reveal to the sheikh’s lawyers what evidence its assessments are based on.

The sheikh’s supporters are outraged that he has been unable to challenge ASIO’s evidence.

Father Gwilym Henry-Edwards from St Luke’s Anglican Church in Sydney says the sheikh has been denied natural justice.

“He hasn’t been able to see what charges have been laid against him or defend himself,” he said.

“I thought that should be a basic human right which should be available to all people.

“It doesn’t matter who they are; it doesn’t matter if they are Australian citizens or not.”

Sheikh Leghaei has always denied being a spy for the Iranian government or spreading a pro-Iranian political message.

He has challenged ASIO’s adverse security assessments in the federal and high courts but failed.

Foreign ‘interference’

In 2007 the sheikh told the ABC that he was unclear why ASIO considered him a threat to national security.

“In all honesty I have no idea what evidence they have. This is one of my wishes in my life,” he said.

“For the past 12 years I was told that I am a risk to national security and I’ve been living here peacefully for more than a decade.”

ASIO found the sheikh had engaged in “acts of foreign interference”.

But Professor Clive Williams from Macquarie University says so-called “acts of foreign interference” can refer to a wide range of activities.

“It’s not very clear. It might be that they’ve been saying things in support of a particular group or they are perhaps straying from religious sermons into other areas,” he said.

Professor Williams says Australia remains concerned about Iran’s nuclear ambitions and support for terrorist groups.

“Iran has made a policy since 1979 of supporting some terrorist groups, namely Hezbollah, the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, Hamas and the Al-Madi army, which isn’t listed as a terrorist group but is active in southern iraq,” he said.

“They have all received assistance from Iran.”

‘Community crisis’

The sheikh’s supporters say that deporting him will create bitterness and resentment in his community.

Reverend David Smith says the decision will create a community crisis.

“I think it will cause enormous reverberations in that community,” he said.

“I don’t know how they will deal with it. But certainly if you are already dealing with a group who are on the wrong end of the stick, it’s not going to help.”

In the past, Sheikh Leghaei has also enjoyed strong support from Australian politicians.

When the Imam Husain Islamic Centre was set up by Sheikh Leghaei in 1997, the then attorney-general Philip Ruddock gave the sheikh his blessing.

“I do note very much the inclusive nature of the centre that you have developed,” he said.

In 1997, while in opposition, Mr McClelland wrote a character reference supporting the sheikh, describing him as an asset to Australia.

As the Federal Attorney-General, Mr McClelland is now responsible for ASIO.

Today a spokesman for his office said: “Those references were made for Dr Leghaei while Mr McClelland was in his capacity as a local member and based on his observations of Dr Leghaei’s work in the local community,” he said.

“Because he was in opposition and not in government, Mr McClelland was not privy to the content of security assessments made about Dr Leghaei at the time.”

‘True blue’

Sheikh Leghaei has four children. Three will be allowed to remain in Australia.

Ali Leghaei arrived in Australia aged four and is now a 20-year-old university student.

Ali arrived on his father’s visa and has been unable to obtain Australian citizenship.

One supporter, Navid Sedaghati, says Ali Leghaei has completed all his education in Australia.

“He undertook his pre-schooling, primary school, high school and university studies in Australia,” he said.

“He is a true blue Aussie. He has been around since the age of four.”

Sheikh Leghaei is lodging a final appeal to the Immigration Minister.

Failing that, he and his wife and son will be deported.

Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei under ‘spy probe’ in Australia

Melbourne, Sep 5 (ANI): Australia’s national security service is investigating Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei, whose legitimacy had been debated by intelligence chiefs in the US, Britain and India, for employing technicians in Australia with direct links to the People’s Liberation Army.

The Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) is investigating claims made by Huawei employees in Sydney and Melbourne, who are understood to have approached the security service with their concerns.

Huawei has been the subject of critical scrutiny by intelligence agencies in the US and Britain about its alleged links with the Chinese military and intelligence apparatus.

The company, which employs more than 100 people in Sydney and about 20 in Melbourne, was founded by former PLA officer Ren Zhengfei, but strongly denies that it does the bidding of the Chinese government or that it has links with the PLA.

It maintains that it is a legitimate telecom company, having been a part of the recent unsuccessful bid by Singtel Optus to build the 15 billion dollars national broadband network, The Australian reported.

The claims made by Huawei employees to ASIO include: That Huawei employs Chinese nationals in Australia who have direct links with the PLA and with the Chinese government; that Huawei has recently sacked several dozen of its Australian-born workforce, replacing them with Chinese nationals brought in from China.

The company says about 30per cent of its workers in Australia are “Chinese expats” and that while there had been recent “adjustments to the allocation and structure of resources,” there had been no wholesale sacking of Australian staff.

A spokesman for Attorney-General Robert McClelland said: “ASIO has frequent contact with the telecommunications industry in Australia. In that context, ASIO contact with Huawei Telecommunications is unsurprising.”

Beijing has vigorously denied claims that it engages in human or cyber espionage in Australia, but in 2004, ASIO set up a new counter-espionage unit to combat the rising incidence of foreign espionage in Australia.

In March, the propaganda chief of the Chinese Communist Party, Li Changchun, visited the company’s Australian headquarters in Sydney. (ANI)

Haneef’s lawyers welcome resignation of AFP chief Keelty

Brisbane (Australia), May 6 (ANI): Lawyers for Indian doctor Mohamed Haneef have welcomed the resignation of Australia Federal Police Commissioner Mick Keelty, saying under him the AFP had been an “organisational disaster”.

Keelty will step down on September 2, his 35th anniversary as a police officer and two years before his second term as police chief expires, The Age reports.

The announcement of his early exit follows increasing pressure on him to resign, particularly over the AFP’s bungled handling of the arrest of Dr Haneef in relation to British terrorism attacks.

A report late last year vindicated Dr Haneef, who was arrested, detained and had his Australian work visa cancelled despite no evidence that he was associated with the British attacks.

“Mick Keelty has provided enormous service to Australia and to the AFP,” Prime Minister Rudd told reporters in Sydney this morning after the news broke.

“I would like to publicly acknowledge the work that he did in response to the Bali bombing where we lost nearly 100 of our own Australians who were murdered in that horrific event,” Rudd said, adding Keelty was leaving of his own accord.

“It is time for him to do something else,” the Prime Minister said.

Keelty, 54, became commissioner in 2001. A career police officer with 35 years experience, he is the first commissioner to have been appointed from within the ranks of the AFP and only the second to have served as commissioner for two terms.

Meanwhile, the Federal Attorney General Robert McClelland has rejected suggestions the investigation into Indian doctor Mohamed Haneef was to blame for the Australian Federal Police commissioner Mick Keelty’s resignation today.

Speaking in Sydney, McClelland congratulated Mick Keelty for a “truly outstanding tour of duty” in his 35 years of service at the AFP, and 9 years as the Commissioner.

According to the Sydney Morning Herald, McClelland rejected suggestions the Haneef debacle had been to blame for Keelty’s resignation. The matter had involved mistakes from the highest levels of government, but Keelty had not been slow to learn the lessons from the affair, he said. (ANI)

Haneef’s lawyers welcome resignation of AFP chief Keelty

Brisbane (Australia), May 6 (ANI): Lawyers for Indian doctor Mohamed Haneef have welcomed the resignation of Australia Federal Police Commissioner Mick Keelty, saying under him the AFP had been an “organisational disaster”.

Keelty will step down on September 2, his 35th anniversary as a police officer and two years before his second term as police chief expires, The Age reports.

The announcement of his early exit follows increasing pressure on him to resign, particularly over the AFP’s bungled handling of the arrest of Dr Haneef in relation to British terrorism attacks.

A report late last year vindicated Dr Haneef, who was arrested, detained and had his Australian work visa cancelled despite no evidence that he was associated with the British attacks.

“Mick Keelty has provided enormous service to Australia and to the AFP,” Prime Minister Rudd told reporters in Sydney this morning after the news broke.

“I would like to publicly acknowledge the work that he did in response to the Bali bombing where we lost nearly 100 of our own Australians who were murdered in that horrific event,” Rudd said, adding Keelty was leaving of his own accord.

“It is time for him to do something else,” the Prime Minister said.

Keelty, 54, became commissioner in 2001. A career police officer with 35 years experience, he is the first commissioner to have been appointed from within the ranks of the AFP and only the second to have served as commissioner for two terms.

Meanwhile, the Federal Attorney General Robert McClelland has rejected suggestions the investigation into Indian doctor Mohamed Haneef was to blame for the Australian Federal Police commissioner Mick Keelty’s resignation today.

Speaking in Sydney, McClelland congratulated Mick Keelty for a “truly outstanding tour of duty” in his 35 years of service at the AFP, and 9 years as the Commissioner.

According to the Sydney Morning Herald, McClelland rejected suggestions the Haneef debacle had been to blame for Keelty’s resignation. The matter had involved mistakes from the highest levels of government, but Keelty had not been slow to learn the lessons from the affair, he said. (ANI)