Doubt cast over Watson’s record attempt

The manager of teenage adventurer Jessica Watson has dismissed talk in sailing circles that she will complete her 200-day journey without achieving her goal – to become the youngest person to sail solo, non-stop and unassisted around the world.

The website Sail-World has published an article saying when Watson arrives in Sydney she will not take Jesse Martin’s record nor will she have even been “around the world”.

Sail-World quoted John Reed, the secretary of the World Sailing Speed Record Council (WSSRC), as saying Watson’s journey does not comply with the definition of around the world and bears no comparison with the achievement of Martin.

But when asked to confirm this was the case, Mr Reed told ABC News Online he made no such statement concerning Watson.

“The WSSRC does not know what route Jessica Watson has taken during her recent voyage,” he said.

“But the WSSRC course for a RTW (round the world) claim is clearly described in rule 26.1.a.”

The website has since removed Mr Reed’s comments and replaced it with a bold section highlighting the council’s rule, which states in part that:

“To sail around the world, a vessel must start from and return to the same point, must cross all meridians of longitude and must cross the equator.

“The shortest orthodromic track of the vessel must be at least 21,600 nautical miles in length calculated based on a perfect sphere.”

Watson will be more than 2,000 nautical miles short of an official record, according to Sail-World editor Rob Kothe.

But Watson’s manager, Andrew Fraser, has dismissed any suggestion she will not break a world record when she arrives in Sydney.

Mr Fraser says the concerns are ludicrous.

“Jess has ticked all those boxes, sailed under the four capes and crossed the equator twice, so in our opinion she will have sailed around the world non-stop, solo, unassisted and travelled almost 23,000 nautical miles in the process,” he said.

“If people want to get caught up with the technical component of a body that doesn’t recognise the record, that’s fine. We can accept that.”

Mr Kothe says by expert calculations, Watson will not break Martin’s record set in 1999 because she did not sail far enough north of the equator.

“We’ve discussed it with her PR team, who weren’t able to give us an exact number, but we gave them a figure of using those calculations of about 18,500 to 19,000 miles,” he said.

He says that leaves her short by 2,500 nautical miles.

“That’s what the WSSRC set up as the definition and that’s the basis on which our records are counted, and that’s the basis on which Jesse Martin sailed around the world,” Mr Kothe said.

“He sailed some 75 miles beyond the minimum distance. And to meet that record – and Jessica could possibly have been the fastest Australian ever to sail around the world, she’s been sailing very quickly – but to meet that, to go into the record books, the official record books of sailing, she would have to sail that distance.”

Mr Kothe says Watson will not be able to claim any officially recognised records.

“What she can claim and everyone will agree, is that she has done, she sailed amazingly well. She’s been a very tough little girl and all Australians should be proud of her,” he said.

Negative publicity

Mr Fraser says he is annoyed about the negative publicity.

“I don’t think anybody can dent her campaign,” he said. “I’m just annoyed that people try and discredit the achievement.

“And that’s OK. We are quite used to that now. She’s had to overcome a lot worse adversity since she started the voyage, so I guess the only positive is that it’s come out now, we can address it and move on.”

He says the WSSRC do not recognise any voyages from sailors under the age of 18, so Watson could never have challenged Martin’s record in the context of the WSSRC criteria.

He says as a result of the WSSRC decision to discontinue recognition of age-related journeys, there is no official body to recognise Jessica’s feat and therefore no official body’s rules that need to be adhered to.

“Jessica actually approached the WSSRC early last year about it and the advice she was given was quite simple. They said they don’t recognise the records,” Mr Fraser told Neil Mitchell on Fairfax Radio.

“It was on her website before we left and everybody knew about it before she left and everything that’s been alluded to was on the website before she left.

“But the particular organisation you’re referring to have decided two weeks out to make some noise probably to drive some traffic to their website.”

Watson is expected to sail into Sydney Harbour on May 16, two days before her 17th birthday.

More dengue cases in far north Qld

Four new cases of dengue fever have been diagnosed in far north Queensland.

A resident north of Tully and three people in the town have contracted locally-acquired cases of the disease.

A dengue fever outbreak was declared in Tully in February, when three people were diagnosed with type-two dengue.

Queensland Health says it is likely the most recent cases are linked to the earlier outbreak.

Young Bulls keep Symonds on

Former Australian all-rounder Andrew Symonds has been included in the Queensland Bulls’ list of contracted players for next season.

The 34-year-old, who has been playing with the Chargers in the IPL, will feature in the Bulls’ Twenty20 campaign only.

“We’ve got a pretty young squad and having players like Andrew along will certainly assist our T20 preparations,” said QC boss Graham Dixon.

“Andrew has been contracted as a T20 player only but no doubt he will provide some valuable advice across the season for the Bulls and QAS squad members.”

Batsmen Glen Batticciotto, Nick Kruger, Greg Moller and paceman Grant Sullivan were all delisted with Queensland Cricket looking further towards the next generation.

Leg-spinner Dan Doran has nominated for the national transfer pool after being overlooked.

Rising batsman Chris Lynn, all-rounder Jason Floros, leg-spinner Cameron Boyce and wicketkeeper Ben Dunk were all promoted from last season’s rookie list to gain full contracts for the first time.

Policeman Luke Feldman, a former Australian Country representative, was also added to the full squad after a superb debut season in which he took 33 first-class wickets at 27.

The Bulls’ 21-man group includes 12 players under 23 and the average age is 23.7, down from 24.6 last season when they lost to Victoria in Sheffield Shield final.

Former Australian coach John Buchanan’s son, Nicholas, a 19-year-old fast bowler, was one of the four new rookies the Bulls named.

Bulls squad: Ryan Harris, James Hopes, Cameron Boyce, Ryan Broad, Lee Carseldine, Ben Cutting, Ben Dunk, Luke Feldman, Jason Floros, Chris Hartley, Ben Laughlin, Chris Lynn, Alister McDermott, Craig Philipson, Nathan Reardon, Nathan Rimmington, Chris Simpson, Chris Swan, Wade Townsend, Scott Walter.

Book to unveil unheard Kennedy interviews

Seven interviews given by Jacqueline Kennedy within months of her husband’s assassination are to be released for the first time.

Publisher Hyperion says the book, to be edited by Ms Kennedy’s daughter, features the former first lady talking about former president John F Kennedy’s plans for a second term.

She also talks about family life in the White House.

The 1964 series of interviews were given to Arthur Schlesinger, a Pulitzer Prize-winning US historian and chronicler of the Kennedy family.

Caroline Kennedy, their only surviving child, decided to release the interviews timed to next year’s 50th anniversary of the slain president’s inauguration, Hyperion said.

She will edit the book to be released in September 2011 with three hours of audio recordings.

Jackie Kennedy had requested that the interviews, conducted in the first half of 1964, be kept sealed for an indefinite amount of time.

She married Greek shipping magnate Aristotle Onassis in 1968 and died in 1994.

The interviews had been intended for the John F Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum as part of an oral history project that captured those close to him in the months after he was shot on November 22, 1963.

“My mother’s passion for history guided and informed her work in the White House,” Caroline Kennedy said in a statement.

“She believed in my father, his vision for America, and in the art of politics. She felt it was important to share her knowledge and excitement with future generations.”

The financial terms of the book deal have not been released.

Crewman ‘possibly affected by alcohol’ when he died

An investigation has found a crewman who died on board a cargo ship at Townsville in 2008 may have been affected by alcohol.

The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) has completed its final report into a fatal incident on the Maltese-registered container ship ‘Spirit of Esperance’.

In November 2008, a crewman died after falling four metres while trying to stow a cargo crane hook while the ship was berthed in Townsville.

The investigation found that the correct procedures were not followed during the docking of the ship and raised concerns about whether safety procedures were routinely met.

It also found that the crewman was probably under the influence of alcohol at the time of the accident which may have affected his reaction time, balance and general ability.

Brisbane seeks solutions for Kingsford Smith traffic congestion

Brisbane Lord Mayor Campbell Newman says the Council is looking at a range of options to ease traffic congestion on Kingsford Smith Drive.

One of the possibilities is a two-kilometre, double-storey tunnel under the Brisbane river between Newstead and Hamilton.

Councillor Newman says improving the bottleneck will be a challenge.

“We’ve got a cliff, houses on top of that hill, and the riverbank,” he said.

“We’ve got nowhere to go, nowhere to manoeuvre and that’s why we’re looking at a variety of different options like widening out over the river, a tunnel or a combination thereof so we’re working on those things.

“We actually have made an early submission to Infrastructure Australia for a sum of $693 million.”

Titans shock Storm without Prince

Gold Coast has defied its reputation as a one-man band with a shock 20-16 upset of NRL premier Melbourne at Robina’s Skilled Stadium.

The Titans, without injured skipper and go-to man Scott Prince, rallied back from 16-4 down to consign the Storm to their first loss of 2010.

A first-half hat-trick from Anthony Quinn and two goals from the boot of Cam Smith put Melbourne ahead by 12 points at the break.

But Gold Coast rallied in the second stanza, with Ashley Harrison and Greg Bird getting over for tries and Mat Rogers hitting two late penalty goals.

Harrison’s try was the perfect gift in his 200th NRL appearance, while former Storm winger Joseph Tomane had earlier scored in the first half for the Titans.

A rare time-wasting penalty helped the Titans stage their bizarre comeback.

Titans five-eighth Bird smashed his way over from the penalty for his first try for the club to lock the game up at 16-16 in the 65th minute before Rogers potted a penalty goal in front of the posts in the 72nd minute to snatch an unlikely victory.

Smith was left stunned when his team was penalised for time-wasting while taking a 64th-minute line drop-out.

Rogers landed another penalty goal after the siren to complete the upset.

It was the second time in two years the Titans have upset Melbourne without Prince, who sat among the 20,083 crowd that were kept on the edge of their seats during the tense final minutes.

Things seemed to be going as planned for the visitors when Quinn crossed for tries in the 14th, 23rd and 30th minutes as both he and Greg Inglis worked over the Titans right-side defence.

Quinn could have had four tries in the opening 40 minutes had video referee Steve Clark not ruled against him in the eighth minute.

Melbourne’s opening try came after Titans half-back Preston Campbell spilled the ball deep in Melbourne’s half only, to see the Storm counter-attack through Cooper Cronk before Quinn crossed for his first.

Tomane put the Titans on the scoreboard with a powerhouse try running through his former Storm team-mate Billy Slater to make it 6-4 soon after.

Quinn was then given the benefit of the doubt by Clark, who took about 10 looks at the replay of a ‘raffle’ involving several players scrambling for a bomb.

There was no doubt about Quinn’s third try down the short side in the 30th minute that gave Melbourne a 16-4 half-time lead, but those were the visitors’ final points.

With more possession in the second half the Titans were able to turn pressure into points as Harrison steamed onto a pass close to the line to cut the lead to 16-10.

Bird was heavily involved, fielding Campbell’s bomb on the last tackle before squeezing a pass to the ever-alert Nathan Friend who found Harrison at full pace.

Gold Coast: 20 (G Bird, A Harrison, J Tomane tries; M Rogers 2/3 conversions, 2 penalties)

Melbourne: 16 (A Quinn 3 tries; C Smith 2/3 conversions)

Dragons torment baby Broncos

Wayne Bennett condemned former club Brisbane to its fourth consecutive loss as the Dragons recovered from round four’s stumble in Melbourne with a 34-16 victory at Wollongong.

Last week’s 17-4 loss to the Storm is the only blot on St George Illawarra’s copybook for 2010, with now four wins from the opening five rounds galvanising its early premiership claims.

An entirely different predicament though surrounds the Broncos, who remain bottom of the league with a 1-4 record and a long list of absentees that makes life extremely difficult for Ivan Henjak.

The Brisbane coach learned the ropes from Bennett, and the current Dragons mentor showed off his mastery at WIN Stadium as a tremendously disciplined outfit towelled up the visitors.

Clinical rugby league has become the hallmark of Bennett’s regime at St George Illawarra, having guided the club to a minor premiership in his first year and on the early evidence another could be in the offing.

The Dragons’ mobile yet physical forward pack laid the platform for Ben Hornby, Jamie Soward and Darius Boyd – the revelation of 2010 – to link up with livewire winger Brett Morris.

The Kangaroos flyer laid on two tries to take his season tally to seven with Hornby, Beau Scott, Jason Nightingale and Dean Young all grabbing four-pointers.

Few recognisable faces lined up for the severely under-strength Broncos with Darren Lockyer, Peter Wallace and Sam Thaiday leading a desperately inexperienced side.

Injury has robbed Henjak of so many options; marquee centres Justin Hodges and Israel Folau are both unavailable, as are Corey Parker, Nick Kenny, Jahral Yow Yeh, Alex Glenn and Steve Michaels.

Ben Teo and Antonio Winterstein were dropped for disciplinary reasons.

Despite the gulf in class, Thaiday spoke of the positives to be taken out of the contest.

“A lot of young boys really put in,” he told Grandstand.

“It’s been hard, we’ve worked hard at training. It seems we always get an injury out of every game.

“It’s something we have to deal with and I’d rather have that happen now than later in the season.”

Much was made during the week of the decision made by Lockyer, 33, to prolong his representative career while the Broncos are faring so poorly in the NRL.

But the Queensland and Australia skipper stood up in a losing performance and gave a glimmer of hope to the club’s suffering fans ahead of next week’s home match against Cronulla.

Michael Weyman paid credit to the character of the young Broncos, acknowledging the fight they put up against one of the competition heavyweights.

“They really put their hand up and had dig,” he said.

“It was one of those games we had to grind out.

“It was a pretty hard game tonight but a win’s a win.”

St George Illawarra: 34 (B Morris 2, B Hornby, J Nightingale, B Scott, D Young tries; J Soward 5/6 conversions)

Brisbane: 16 (D Copley, J Hoffman, A McCullough tries; P Wallace 2 goals)

Schwarten promises shortchanged QBuild workers will be paid

Queensland Public Works Minister Robert Schwarten has promised to pay back QBuild workers who have not received overtime and allowances.

The State Government says 450 workers have been shortchanged over three pay cycles although unions say more than a thousand people have been affected over the past eight weeks.

Mr Schwarten says a glitch in the payroll system is to blame and it should not have happened.

“We won’t leave them adrift,” he said.

“Everybody’s entitled to get paid and we’ll make sure they do anybody owed more than $100 should have been contacted already.

“That money should have been put in their bank accounts so I don’t understand the claim that people are unable to pay their mortgages when in fact everybody’s got their base pay for a start.”

The Government has promised an independent review into unrelated pay problems at Queensland Health which have shortchanged almost 3,000 workers.

Oil pumped from grounded coal ship

Salvagers have pumped almost 40 tonnes of oil from a coal carrier grounded on the Great Barrier Reef off central Queensland.

It has been almost a week since the Shen Neng ran aground on Douglas Shoal, spilling more than two tonnes of oil.

Authorities are now pumping out more than 970 tonnes of fuel oil still on the ship.

Queensland Premier Anna Bligh says the ship’s insurer will be forced to pay for the salvage operation and the Government will recoup its expenses from the insurance company.

“But that is a matter for down the track,” she said.

“Number one priority – get this ship out of this reef safely without any damage to the reef.”

Ms Bligh says the shipping company could face fines of up to a million dollars over the incident.

Reporting dispute

Australian maritime authorities are disputing a claim that the grounding was reported within five minutes.

In a statement on Friday the Chinese state-owned Shenzhen Energy Transport apologised for the incident saying it is cooperating with authorities.

The company says it alerted Australian authorities about five minutes after the ship ran aground but the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) disputes the claim, saying it was not told for about an-hour-and-a-half.

It then took another 25 minutes for Maritime Safety Queensland to become involved.

AMSA has asked the Chinese company to clarify its comments.

There was criticism last year that authorities took too long to act after a major oil spill off south-east Queensland.

Could take days

Meanwhile, authorities are putting safety equipment in place to reduce the risk of a further spill as they prepare to pump out the remaining fuel.

About 250 workers are on standby should any oil reach the coast.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) general manager Patrick Quirk says it could take days to transfer all the oil.

“This is just a part of a long process and we need to keep our eye on the short game, which is the pumping of the oil,” he said.

“The medium-term game is the refloating and what we’re going to do when we refloat her.”

Mr Quirk says the carrier is holding together.

“The salvors have put on electronic monitoring, hull-monitoring equipment and they have advised that they are detecting no further deflections of the hull, which means that the damage has stabilised,” he said.

“We’re doing a metre-by-metre check of the ship with the salvors and that will determine what goes into the computer programs in terms of the damage-assessment reports.”

Mr Quirk says the weather conditions today are favourable.

“A bit of a wind change due Monday which we’ll need to keep our eye on, but at the moment we’re not being alarmed by the weather change,” he said.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says the oil transfer is a difficult and delicate operation.

“Anyone who thinks this is all over red rover, frankly, they’re not getting it right,” he said.

“This is going to take a lot of time, a lot of technical precision and hard work and it’s a very difficult situation still with no absolute guarantee of success.”

Political ‘sightseeing’

Meanwhile, Queensland Opposition Leader John-Paul Langbroek has criticised Premier Anna Bligh for travelling to inspect the stricken coal carrier.

Ms Bligh will today fly over the ship.

Mr Langbroek say Ms Bligh is the fourth Labor politician to go and look at the damage.

“I think it’s interesting that Anna Bligh is following the example of Kevin Rudd, [Federal Environment Minister] Peter Garrett and [Queensland Transport Minister] Rachel Nolan to be the fourth senior politician to take a plane flight over the Shen Neng 1,” he said.

“I think it’s time for the sightseeing to stop by senior politicians and let’s just let the experts get on with fixing it.”

- Reporting by Paul Robinson, Maria Hatzakis, Kerrin Binnie and Natalie Poyhonen

Man fronts Ipswich court charged with murder

A 36-year-old man has appeared in court charged with the murder of Amanda Quirk from Ipswich west of Brisbane.

Christopher James Swan from Lawnton north of Brisbane has been remanded in custody to appear in the Ipswich Magistrates Court again next month.

Ms Quirk who was 32 was reported missing on Tuesday.

Police say a woman’s body found in northern New South Wales yesterday is yet to be formally identified.

A 32-year-old woman from Ipswich has been charged with being an accessory after the fact.

Asian exhibition at Qld Art Gallery ‘a hit’

The Queensland Art Gallery says an exhibition of modern art works from Asia and the Pacific has been a hit with audiences.

The sixth Asia Pacific Triennial of Contemporary Art in Brisbane included installations from artists in North Korea, Burma and China.

On average 4,000 people a day attended the exhibition, which ended its four-month run on Monday.

Works on show ranged from a stuffed deer covered in glass bulbs to reggae music from the Pacific Islands.

The Queensland Art Gallery’s deputy director Lynne Seear says audiences are becoming more attracted to modern art.

“They’re contemporary thinkers in Queensland,” she said.

“They want to know what’s happening in the world, what’s happening now, what’s current.”

The event also proved popular beyond Queensland’s borders with a quarter of visitors coming from interstate.

Qantas apologises for recent problems

Qantas boss Alan Joyce has defended the airline’s safety record after a string of mechanical problems.

Seven Qantas planes have suffered equipment failures over the past two weeks including a cracked windscreen, brake issues and wing flap defects.

Mr Joyce says he is sorry about the delays but safety is not an issue for the airline.

“The issues that occurred over Easter we apologise for – the inconvenience that would cause to customers,” he said.

“But they don’t signal a deterioration in Qantas safety and maintenance records because the statistics clearly indicate that this happens to every airline in the world.”

Peruvian loses appeal against drug trafficking conviction

A Peruvian man jailed in Queensland over a conspiracy to import almost 90 kilograms of high-grade cocaine has lost an appeal against his conviction and 24-year jail term.

A Supreme Court jury in Brisbane last year convicted Jorge Velarde Silva of conspiring to bring 89 kilograms of cocaine into Australia from Mexico on board the yacht Sparkles Plenty.

The conspiracy, which involved two other men, ran into trouble when the yacht almost sank in Moreton Bay.

Velarde argued his trial judge made mistakes and his sentence was manifestly excessive.

But the Court of Appeal has ruled there were no grounds to overturn the conviction and the sentence emphasised the need for deterrence.

Fevola cleared over nude Bingle photo

Brisbane Lions forward Brendan Fevola has escaped punishment over his involvement in the Lara Bingle nude photo affair, with the AFL concluding there is insufficient evidence to establish guilt.

AFL football operations general manager Adrian Anderson said while Fevola admitted taking the photograph, it could not be proved that he had distributed it to other players.

“Given the evidence currently available to us and the time elapsed since the alleged behaviour, the AFL has not established that a breach of our rules has occurred,” he said.

“However, we will continue to monitor whether there are legal proceedings arising from this matter and the AFL remains willing to speak with Ms Bingle.”

The investigation by the AFL’s manager of integrity services, Brett Clothier, and cultural strategy and education manager, Sue Clark, followed claims Fevola took a nude photograph of Bingle during their brief relationship in 2006 and distributed it to other AFL players.

The former Carlton player was interviewed twice as part of the investigation while Bingle, through her lawyers, declined to speak directly with the AFL but provided a statutory declaration.

Mr Anderson said the AFL does not condone any behaviour which shows a lack of respect towards women.

“All AFL players and officials should be aware that taking and distributing private images without consent is unacceptable and can result in sanctions under the AFL player rules,” he said.

Man charged with rape of child

Brisbane man Massimo “Max” Sica has been indicted on 20 child sex charges in the District Court.

The charges include one count of maintaining a sexual relationship with a girl under 16 years, two counts of rape, six counts of unlawful carnal knowledge with a child and nine counts of indecent dealing with a child.

It is alleged the girl was aged between 9 and 13 at the time of the offences, between 2004 and 2008.

The matter has been adjourned until May 10 in the Brisbane District Court.

Teachers sue paper over Facebook photos

Two teachers are taking legal action against a southern Queensland newspaper for publishing photographs of them taken from the social networking site Facebook.

The Warwick Daily News published an article last month with photos showing the teachers posing in schoolgirl uniforms.

Solicitor Rebecca Jancauskas says the story vilified the teachers.

“The global publication of this story has caused our clients incredible distress and has damaged their personal and professional reputations immeasurably,” she said.

“They’re now a laughing stock in their local community, their students and their peers view them very differently and their professional lives hang in the balance while Education Queensland decide the outcome of their investigation.”

Ms Jancauskas says the case will have wider ramifications for social media sites.

“I think it raises interesting issues that need to be determined, whether it be by a court or by a government, which is do user generated sites such as Facebook have the legal status of a modern day diary or personal correspondence?” she said.

New Hope makes $3.7b bid for Macarthur Coal

Queensland-based miner Macarthur Coal has confirmed it has received a takeover bid from fellow miner New Hope.

The proposal values Macarthur at just over $3.7 billion and would give New Hope 2.7 shares for each Macarthur share. That represents a total value of $14.58 per share, which is more than the US coal miner Peabody’s earlier offer of $14 per share.

Macarthur Coal says New Hope’s offer is conditional on Macarthur abandoning its takeover bid for Gloucester Coal.

Fresh Nuttall trial not until next year

Former Queensland Government minister Gordon Nuttall will not face trial on further corruption charges until next year.

Nuttall was charged last August with five counts of receiving corrupt payments and perjury after a Crime and Misconduct Commission (CMC) investigation.

The matter was mentioned briefly in the District Court in Brisbane this morning where legal representatives said they would not be ready to go to trial until the new year.

Nuttall is serving a seven-year jail sentence after being convicted last year on more than 30 counts of receiving secret commissions.

Next year’s trial is expected to take two weeks.

Patel’s prosecution costs $2.75m so far: Government

The Queensland Government has revealed it has spent more than $2.75 million on the prosecution of former Bundaberg-based surgeon Jayant Patel.

Patel, 59, has pleaded not guilty to unlawfully killing three patients and to causing grievous bodily harm to a fourth man during his time as director of surgery at the Bundaberg hospital in southern Queensland.

In response to a Question on Notice from the Member for Bundaberg, Jack Dempsey, the Government says it has budgeted just over $3 million for the trial, with $2.75 million already spent.

Meanwhile, the Supreme Court trial in Brisbane today has heard Patel assured a patient of good outcomes from a complex surgical procedure, but the patient died two days after the operation.

James Phillips, 46, was in renal failure in 2003 when Patel removed part of his oesophagus to treat a throat cancer.

Mr Phillips died two days later.

Bundaberg hospital renal nurse Carolyn Waters gave evidence about a conversation between Mr Phillips and Patel prior to the surgery.

She told the court Patel assured Mr Phillips that he had previously had good outcomes from the procedure and Bundaberg hospital could provide the necessary care afterwards.

But she says he did not tell Mr Phillips he might die.

Another nurse has told the court that Patel described a detailed note in a patient’s file before surgery as necessary because of the chance of a lawsuit.

Nurse Mandy McDonald told the trial when she commented about a detailed note Patel wrote about Mr Phillips before surgery, he replied it was necessary because ‘you never knew when you might get sued’.