Catholic Church unfairly attacked: cardinal

The child sex abuse crimes of individual priests are not the fault of the Roman Catholic Church as a whole, a top Vatican cardinal said overnight, lamenting what he called “unfair attacks”.

“Christians feel rightly hurt when there is an attempt to embroil them in the serious and painful matters of some priests, transforming individual faults and responsibilities into collective ones,” said Angelo Sodano, the dean of the Vatican’s College of Cardinals.

“Now the accusation of paedophilia is being brandished against the Church,” Cardinal Sodano said in an interview with Vatican newspaper L’Osservatore Romano.

He added: “In the face of these unfair attacks we are being told that our strategy is wrong, that we should react differently. The Church has its own style… the only strategy that we have comes from the Gospel”.

Also Tuesday, Vatican Radio warned of what it called an “anti-Catholic media campaign of hatred”.

Referring to graffiti that was scrawled on a church in Italy, an Easter assault on Bishop Felix Genn of Muenster, Germany, and other disturbances at Easter gatherings, the radio said: “Some fear that the anti-Catholic media campaign of hatred could get worse.”

Vatican Radio singled out the Wall Street Journal as going against the trend, saying it had maintained that Pope Benedict had “done more than anyone else” to make priests accountable for their crimes.

Large-scale paedophilia scandals have rocked the churches of Ireland, Austria, the United States and the Pope’s native Germany in recent months.

The pontiff, 82, has himself faced criticism over claims that, as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger when he headed the Vatican’s watchdog over morals and doctrinal issues and earlier as the archbishop of Munich, he failed to take action against predator priests.

Pope admits Church in ‘times of difficulty’

Pope Benedict has acknowledged that the Roman Catholic Church is in “times of difficulty” but avoided direct comment on sex abuse, as the Vatican faced fresh criticism over a string of scandals.

After a series of paedophile priest revelations cast a pall over the holiest week in the Christian calendar, the embattled pontiff spoke of priests’ special responsibilities to society in an Easter Monday prayer.

The Pope told hundreds of followers at Castel Gandolfo near Rome that “the loving presence [of Christ] accompanies the church on its path and supports it in times of difficulty”.

“Priests, ministers of Christ, have a special responsibility,” said the 82-year-old pontiff, appearing calm and smiling, adding that they should be “messengers of victory over evil and death”.

Many of the assembled worshippers waved banners of support.

But the Pope again kept mum on the abuse scandals which have reached Benedict himself with claims that he helped shield predator priests when head of the Vatican department charged with disciplining them and as archbishop of Munich.

Large-scale paedophile scandals have rocked the Irish, Austrian, Swiss, German and US churches in recent weeks.

The Vatican has largely adopted a strategy of blaming the media for playing up the paedophile revelations.

Top prelates closed ranks around the Pope on Easter Sunday, with the dean of the Vatican’s College of Cardinals, Angelo Sodano, saying in an unusual gesture that “the people of God are with you” and would ignore “idle chatter”.

On Friday the Pope’s personal preacher, Father Raniero Cantalamessa, evoked a parallel between attacks on the Pope and anti-Semitism – remarks for which he later apologised after condemnation by Jewish groups and abuse victims.

Abuse furore continues as Catholics observe EasterAbuse furore continues as Catholics observe Easter

Pope Benedict has presided over Easter ceremonies, as Catholic leaders defend the 82-year-old over criticism of his handling of the Church’s widening sex abuse scandal.

The Pontiff led a service at St Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican, before attending a traditional procession at Rome’s Colosseum that re-enacted Jesus’s final hours and crucifixion.

Pope Benedict has been beset by allegations he covered up child abuse before he became the Pope – claims vehemently denied by the Vatican.

Several senior Catholics have rallied around the Pontiff in his defence.

Pope Benedict’s personal preacher has compared criticism of the Pope over the Church’s widening paedophilia scandals to “the collective violence suffered by the Jews”.

Speaking in a Good Friday sermon in St Peter’s Basilica in Rome, Father Raniero Cantalamessa quoted from a letter he said he had received from a Jewish friend.

He says his friend wrote that the the shifting of personal responsibility and guilt to a collective guilt reminded him of the most shameful aspects of anti-Semitism.

Angry reaction

Jewish communities around the world have reacted angrily.

Rabbi David Goldberg, from the Liberal Jewish Synagogue in London, says the comments are out of touch but not malign in intent.

“My reaction is now more one of sorrow, that a man could have made such a pitifully inept analogy to try and defend the church,” he said.

Rabbi Marvin Hier from the Simon Wiesenthal Centre in the United States agrees.

“The Church should know better,” he said.

“There is no comparison between collective guilt assigned against the Jews, which resulted in the death of tens of millions of innocent civilians, to the so-called accusations levelled against perpetrators,” he said.

Rabbi Marvin Hier says to make the remarks on Easter Friday in Saint Peter’s Basilica is outrageous, even if Father Cantalamessa was quoting a Jewish friend.

“It’s like, I will quote the Jewish friend who says the world is flat. Doesn’t mean I need to quote it on Easter Friday in the presence of the Pope,” he said.

“It’s a stupid remark and the comparison is ridiculous. It’s a person who doesn’t know history.

“The difference is that tens of millions of people died because of the other comparison, because of the collective guilt.

“Here, there’s no collective guilt. The charges have been levelled against priests who have abused their calling and the hierarchy that covered it up.”

Rabbi Hier called for a high-ranking Vatican official to denounce the comments.

“If for some reason the Pope doesn’t want himself [to] say that the comparison is shameful, because he himself has been brought into the scandal involved in the priests, he could have the Vatican secretary of state say it,” he said.

The timing and nature of the controversial sermon has not been lost on the Jewish leader closest to the Vatican.

The Chief Rabbi of Rome, Riccardo di Segni, reportedly laughed in seeming disbelief when asked about Father Cantalamessa’s remarks.

He told the New York Times, “With a minimum of irony, I will say that today is Good Friday.

“When they pray that the Lord illuminate our hearts, so we recognise Jesus, we also pray that the Lord illuminate theirs.”

The Vatican’s official spokesman says the comments were the priest’s “private thoughts” and do not reflect the church’s official position.

Victims failed

In Pope Benedict’s home country of Germany, the leader of the Roman Catholic Church, Archbishop Robert Zollitsch, acknowledged the church had failed victims, putting the reputation of the church ahead of them.

In an Easter message, he spoke of the wounds that may never be healed and the shame felt by Catholics.

He says Good Friday must mark a new departure which the church so badly needs.

Last month the Archbishop apologised to victims of abuse by German priests.

A church hotline for the victims was opened and within hours received more than 4,000 calls.

No mention of sex abuse during Easter mass

Pope Benedict has delivered his three-hour Easter Sunday Mass without mentioning the sex abuse crisis shaking the Roman Catholic Church.

The Pope was under pressure to speak out on the crisis, but instead he spoke of Christians suffering persecution in Pakistan and Iraq and called for a true exodus from conflict in the Middle East.

He also urged humanity to undergo a “spiritual and moral conversion”.

But while the Pope’s message made no mention of the paedophile priest scandal, other church leaders across Europe were bolder.

An archbishop in Germany spoke of the “church’s dark aspects”, while in Belgium an archbishop said the church had mismanaged the crisis “with a guilty silence”.

But others including the Archbishop of Paris echoed the Vatican line, criticising the world’s media for its “smear campaign aimed at the Pope”.

‘Idle chatter’

The Vatican’s Easter mass kicked off with an unusual greeting from the dean of the College of Cardinals, who told the Pope the “people of God are with you and do not allow themselves to be impressed by the idle chatter of the moment”.

Cardinal Angelo Sodano was reprising the same phrase Pope Benedict used a week ago when he urged Christians “not be intimidated by the idle chatter of prevailing opinions”.

The 82-year-old Pope looked to the future in his traditional Urbi et Orbi message.

He called for a “true exodus” from conflict in the Middle East, urged prayer for quake-ravaged Haiti and condemned the persecution of Christian minorities.

“May the risen lord sustain the Christians who suffer persecution and even death for their faith, as for example in Pakistan,” he said.

“To the Christian communities who are experiencing trials and sufferings, especially in Iraq … peace be with you.”

Meanwhile, the Pope’s personal preacher has apologised for drawing a parallel between attacks on the Pope and anti-Semitism in his Good Friday sermon.

Jewish groups and those representing victims of abuse by Catholic priests condemned Father Raniero Cantalamessa for quoting the comments, which he said were made in a letter from a Jewish friend.

Easter service clouded by Church abuse scandal

Pope Benedict has led the world’s Catholics into Easter with the holiest day of the liturgical calendar clouded by persistent allegations of sexual abuse of children by priests.

The 82-year-old Pope presided at an Easter Eve service that began late in the night (local time) in St Peter’s Basilica.

During the service, he received six adult converts into the Church and administered the sacraments of Baptism and Confirmation to them.

Wearing gold vestments and looking tired, he weaved his sermon around the theme of eternal life.

In the past three days of Holy Week services he has made no reference to the scandal that has sorely hurt the Church’s image around the world, particularly in Europe and the United States.

The celebrations leading up to Easter Sunday have been clouded by accusations the Church in several countries mishandled and covered up episodes of sexual abuse of children by priests, some dating back decades.

In response, the Vatican has accused the media of attempting to smear the Pope.

Some reports have accused him of negligence in handling abuse cases in previous roles as a cardinal in Germany and in Rome.

The Vatican has denied any cover-up over the abuse of 200 deaf boys in the United States by Reverend Lawrence Murphy from 1950 to 1974.

The New York Times reported the Vatican and Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict, were warned about Murphy but he was not defrocked.

This year, Easter and the Jewish Passover fell in the same week.

In Jerusalem the coincidence has prompted ecumenical gatherings during Holy Week.

At the Church of the Holy Sepulchre thousands of locals and foreigners packed the many corners of the ancient church for the ceremony of the Holy Fire, which symbolises the resurrection of Jesus after his death on the cross.

Roman Catholics and Protestants, however, eschew the Holy Fire rite. Western visitors have for centuries scoffed at the ceremony in which the Greek Orthodox patriarch of Jerusalem produces a lighted candle from the sealed and empty tomb without the aid of matches or other, visible, terrestrial aids.

Jewish outrage

Jewish leaders from around the world have condemned a Good Friday sermon by the Pope’s personal preacher, Father Raniero Cantalamessa, in which he said the attacks on the Catholic Church and the pope over the sexual abuse scandal were comparable to “collective violence” against Jews.

An international Jewish rights group spokesman, Rabbi Marvin Hier, also condemned the comments.

“How can you compare the collective guilt assigned to the Jews, which caused the deaths of tens of millions of innocent people, to perpetrators who abuse their faith and their calling by sexually abusing children?” he said.

A Vatican spokesman says the comparison “is absolutely not the line of the Vatican and of the Catholic Church”.

Victims of sexual abuse also criticised Father Cantalamessa.

“This ridiculous attempt to hide the crimes of the [Church] hierarchy inside of Jewish suffering shows just how far this pope seems willing to go to stop the truth from emerging,” said Peter Isely, a spokesman for the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP).

Jews outraged at Vatican scandal comparison

Jewish groups around the world have reacted with shock after Pope Benedict’s personal preacher compared attacks on the Church and the pope over a sexual abuse scandal to “collective violence” against Jews.

The Pope’s personal preacher, Father Raniero Cantalamessa, made the comments during a Friday sermon in St Peter’s Basilica.

Father Cantalamessa, speaking with the Pope sitting nearby, said Jews throughout history had been the victims of “collective violence” and drew comparisons between Jewish suffering and attacks on the Church.

“The use of stereotypes, the shifting of personal responsibility and guilt to a collective guilt remind me of the most shameful aspects of anti-Semitism,” he quoted from a letter he said he had received from a Jewish friend.

A former president of Italy’s Jewish communities, Amos Luzzatto, says he is finds the preacher’s comments dumbfounding.

Rome chief rabbi Riccardo Di Segni, who welcomed the Pope in the capital’s synagogue last January, also says the comments are “really in bad taste”.

Jewish leaders around the world used words like repugnant, obscene and offensive to describe the sermon, particularly, as chief rabbi Di Segni noted, it came on the day that for centuries Christians prayed for the conversion of the Jews who were once held collectively responsible for Jesus’ death.

An international Jewish rights group spokesman, Rabbi Marvin Hier, also condemned the comments.

“How can you compare the collective guilt assigned to the Jews, which caused the deaths of tens of millions of innocent people, to perpetrators who abuse their faith and their calling by sexually abusing children?” he said.

A Vatican spokesman says the comparison “is absolutely not the line of the Vatican and of the Catholic Church”.

Victims of sexual abuse also criticised Father Cantalamessa.

“This ridiculous attempt to hide the crimes of the [Church] hierarchy inside of Jewish suffering shows just how far this pope seems willing to go to stop the truth from emerging,” said Peter Isely, a spokesman for the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP).

Meanwhile the Vatican’s newspaper continued its campaign against the media for its reports on alleged cover-ups of sexual abuse of children by priests, saying the Pope had become the target of “despicable campaign of defamation”.

Australian clerical abuse victims want apology

An Australian victims group says the Pope should apologise to abuse victims in Australia, as well as people who were abused by priests in Ireland.

In a 13-page letter to Irish victims, the Pontiff has criticised the way bishops handled the church’s sexual abuse scandal, saying some of them made serious mistakes.

Pope Benedict has admitted the bishops had “a misplaced concern for the reputation of the Church and the avoidance of scandal”.

But Care Leavers Australia Network president Leonie Sheedy says the same things happened in Australia.

“I’d like the Pope to acknowledge what happened to us in the Catholic institutions in Australia,” she said.

“We suffered emotional, physical, psychological and sexual abuse.”

Irish disappointment

Irish victims of abuse say they are deeply disappointed by the Pope’s letter of apology.

A group representing victims says it fails to address the role of senior Church leaders.

“My first response was deep disappointment in the letter,” said Maeve Lewis, executive director of victims group One in Four.

“We feel the letter falls far short of addressing the concerns of the victims.”

She said the Pope’s letter focused too narrowly on lower-rank Irish priests without recognising the responsibility of the Vatican and senior Irish clerics for protecting offenders and dealing with victims.

“There is nothing in this letter to suggest that any new vision of leadership in the Catholic Church exists,” she said.

The letter also does not refer to the resignation of the head of the church in Ireland, Cardinal Sean Brady, which victims groups have demanded, she said.

Pope Benedict expressed his “shame and remorse” for episodes of child sex abuse, saying “serious mistakes” were made by Irish bishops in responding to allegations.

“You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry,” the Pope said in the letter signed on Friday.

He said priests and religious workers guilty of child abuse “must answer” for their crimes “before properly constituted tribunals”.

“Openly acknowledge your guilt, submit yourselves to the demands of justice, but do not despair of God’s mercy,” he said, addressing himself to offenders.

The Pope announced a mission to Irish dioceses rocked by sex scandals to assist “the local church on her path to renewal” and said he was ready to meet again with victims of child abuse.

Predominantly Catholic Ireland has been shocked by three judicial reports in the past five years that revealed ill-treatment, abuse and cruelty by clerics and a cover-up of their activities by church authorities.

New abuse scandals have also come to light in the Pope’s native Germany, Austria, the Netherlands and Switzerland.

- ABC/AFP/Reuters

Victims disappointed by Pope abuse letter

Irish victims of clerical child sexual abuse are deeply disappointed by Pope Benedict’s letter of apology as it fails to address the role of senior church leaders, a group representing victims said.

“My first response was deep disappointment in the letter,” said Maeve Lewis, executive director of victims group One in Four.

“We feel the letter falls far short of addressing the concerns of the victims.”

She said the Pope’s letter focused too narrowly on lower-rank Irish priests without recognising the responsibility of the Vatican and senior Irish clerics for protecting offenders and dealing with victims.

“There is nothing in this letter to suggest that any new vision of leadership in the Catholic church exists,” she said.

The letter also does not refer to the resignation of the head of the church in Ireland, Cardinal Sean Brady, which victims groups have demanded, she said.

Pope Benedict expressed his “shame and remorse” for episodes of child sex abuse, saying “serious mistakes” were made by Irish bishops in responding to allegations.

“You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry,” the Pope said in the letter signed on Friday.

He said priests and religious workers guilty of child abuse “must answer” for their crimes “before properly constituted tribunals”.

“Openly acknowledge your guilt, submit yourselves to the demands of justice, but do not despair of God’s mercy,” he said, addressing himself to offenders.

The Pope announced a mission to Irish dioceses rocked by sex scandals to assist “the local church on her path to renewal” and said he was ready to meet again with victims of child abuse.

Predominantly Catholic Ireland has been shocked by three judicial reports in the past five years that revealed ill-treatment, abuse and cruelty by clerics and a cover-up of their activities by church authorities.

New abuse scandals have also come to light in the Pope’s native Germany, Austria, the Netherlands and Switzerland.

- AFP/Reuters

The ‘living shrine’ Indian woman who cries tears of blood

London, Apr 9 (ANI): Indian woman Rashida Khatoon has been dubbed a ‘living miracle’ because she cries tears of blood.

According to the Austrian Times, the women of Patna in Bihar has become a ‘holy shrine’ where people see her weep blood several times a day.

Even the doctors are stunned at Khatoon’s condition.

“I do not feel any pain when it happens but it’s a shock to see blood instead of water,” the Daily Star quoted her as saying.

The local Hindu holy men have declared her a living miracle.

People visit her home daily to see her cry blood and have even showered her and her family with gifts as holy offerings. (ANI)