Concerns hospital centralisation could compromise regional areas

There are plans to stop the State Government’s plan to run Tasmania’s hospitals out of Hobart.

The Government has admitted it is leaning towards a centralised system, rather than the locally run hospitals preferred by the Federal Government.

Independent member for the Western Tiers Greg Hall says he will introduce a motion in the Upper House opposing the system.

He says there is a danger regional Tasmanians will miss out on health services under a centralised system.

“If the decision making is centralised in Hobart, the concern is that the services will be centralised, which means that a lot of people from the northern part of the state might then have to travel to Hobart for medical treatment, and I think that we always have to remember that Tasmania is a very decentralised state,” he said.

Mr Hall says he will oppose the plan.

“When Parliament sits again in budget week, I will move a notice of motion that if the current position is not reversed, then it ought to be reversed.”

Federal Court hears arguments over NAPLAN dispute

The Federal Court has heard the Australian Education Union (AEU) is not acting in the broad educational interest by threatening to boycott national literacy and numeracy tests.

More than 1.1 million year three, five, seven and nine students are scheduled to sit the NAPLAN test next week.

The AEU argues the test results data will be used to unfairly rank schools.

It is pressing ahead with plans for a test boycott despite a Fair Work Australia ruling yesterday finding that the proposed industrial action is unlawful.

Lawyers for the Government’s Fair Work ombudsman have told a Federal Court hearing in Melbourne that the union is acting only in the interests of teachers, rather than in broad educational interests.

The court has heard massive logistical preparations have been made to deliver the test and the matter is urgent.

The union’s lawyers told the court the data would be false and inaccurate and would lead to teachers being badgered by parents.

The hearing continues.

Any Federal Court ruling on Naplan test boycotts will only affect Victoria, the Northern Territory and the ACT, where teachers come under the federal award system.

Oil pumped from grounded coal ship

Salvagers have pumped almost 40 tonnes of oil from a coal carrier grounded on the Great Barrier Reef off central Queensland.

It has been almost a week since the Shen Neng ran aground on Douglas Shoal, spilling more than two tonnes of oil.

Authorities are now pumping out more than 970 tonnes of fuel oil still on the ship.

Queensland Premier Anna Bligh says the ship’s insurer will be forced to pay for the salvage operation and the Government will recoup its expenses from the insurance company.

“But that is a matter for down the track,” she said.

“Number one priority – get this ship out of this reef safely without any damage to the reef.”

Ms Bligh says the shipping company could face fines of up to a million dollars over the incident.

Reporting dispute

Australian maritime authorities are disputing a claim that the grounding was reported within five minutes.

In a statement on Friday the Chinese state-owned Shenzhen Energy Transport apologised for the incident saying it is cooperating with authorities.

The company says it alerted Australian authorities about five minutes after the ship ran aground but the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) disputes the claim, saying it was not told for about an-hour-and-a-half.

It then took another 25 minutes for Maritime Safety Queensland to become involved.

AMSA has asked the Chinese company to clarify its comments.

There was criticism last year that authorities took too long to act after a major oil spill off south-east Queensland.

Could take days

Meanwhile, authorities are putting safety equipment in place to reduce the risk of a further spill as they prepare to pump out the remaining fuel.

About 250 workers are on standby should any oil reach the coast.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) general manager Patrick Quirk says it could take days to transfer all the oil.

“This is just a part of a long process and we need to keep our eye on the short game, which is the pumping of the oil,” he said.

“The medium-term game is the refloating and what we’re going to do when we refloat her.”

Mr Quirk says the carrier is holding together.

“The salvors have put on electronic monitoring, hull-monitoring equipment and they have advised that they are detecting no further deflections of the hull, which means that the damage has stabilised,” he said.

“We’re doing a metre-by-metre check of the ship with the salvors and that will determine what goes into the computer programs in terms of the damage-assessment reports.”

Mr Quirk says the weather conditions today are favourable.

“A bit of a wind change due Monday which we’ll need to keep our eye on, but at the moment we’re not being alarmed by the weather change,” he said.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says the oil transfer is a difficult and delicate operation.

“Anyone who thinks this is all over red rover, frankly, they’re not getting it right,” he said.

“This is going to take a lot of time, a lot of technical precision and hard work and it’s a very difficult situation still with no absolute guarantee of success.”

Political ‘sightseeing’

Meanwhile, Queensland Opposition Leader John-Paul Langbroek has criticised Premier Anna Bligh for travelling to inspect the stricken coal carrier.

Ms Bligh will today fly over the ship.

Mr Langbroek say Ms Bligh is the fourth Labor politician to go and look at the damage.

“I think it’s interesting that Anna Bligh is following the example of Kevin Rudd, [Federal Environment Minister] Peter Garrett and [Queensland Transport Minister] Rachel Nolan to be the fourth senior politician to take a plane flight over the Shen Neng 1,” he said.

“I think it’s time for the sightseeing to stop by senior politicians and let’s just let the experts get on with fixing it.”

- Reporting by Paul Robinson, Maria Hatzakis, Kerrin Binnie and Natalie Poyhonen

NSW lobbies for police killer’s deportation

The New South Wales Government and Police Commissioner are pushing the Federal Government to ensure a man convicted of killing an officer is deported upon his release from jail.

Motekiai Taufahema could be free in two years, after serving his minimum sentence over the shooting death of Sydney highway patrol officer Senior Constable Glenn McEnally in 2002.

Taufahema’s visa was initially revoked by the Immigration Department, meaning he would be deported to Tonga when he was released.

But earlier this year, the prisoner took the matter to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which sided with him, prompting the Federal Government to appeal.

Two days ago, the Government lost that appeal in the Federal Court, effectively allowing Taufahema’s visa to be extended so he will not be deported.

The police union says the Government should now take the issue to the full bench of the Federal Court.

“What we need to see is the Minister for Immigration, Senator Chris Evans, continuing to show strong leadership on this issue and exhaust all legal avenues to overturn this decision,” the union’s Scott Weber said.

“This crook, this killer, has been in Australia for 21 years and he spent 12 of those behind bars in prison. He has a lengthy record of criminal violence.”

The Federal Government has a three-week window to decide whether to lodge another appeal.

NSW Police Minister Michael Daley says he has backed the union for the duration of the campaign.

Mr Daley has expressed his gratitude at Senator Evans’ response so far.

“I now once again say to the Federal Government on behalf of all police officers in NSW that they do everything in their power to make sure this guy does not become an Australian citizen,” the Minister said.

“He’s not a good character, he doesn’t deserve to stay here, the police want him out and I support that call.”

Police Commissioner Andrew Scipione agrees.

“Somebody that plays a part in the death of a police officer, I think, rules out and disqualifies himself from any opportunity to stay here as a long-term resident,” he says. “It’s best if he goes home.”

The union says it is not happy with the way the Administrative Appeals Tribunal reached its original decision in favour of Taufahema.

“A major concern for NSW Police is that they weren’t notified in regards to the lodging of this appeal against his visa cancellation,” Mr Weber said.

“Therefore, the police were deprived of giving the tribunal important information that could have changed the outcome.

“That’s resulted in an unacceptable situation where this killer of a policeman will be welcomed back into the community.”

Four men were jailed over the death of Senior Constable McEnally, who was shot at Hilllsdale, in Sydney’s south, while pursuing a stolen car that Taufahema was driving.

Both Motekiai Taufahemea and his brother, John, are serving 11-year jail sentences after pleading guilty to manslaughter.

Wheatbelt mental service granted $1.4m

The Federal Government has boosted funding to support services for people in the Wheatbelt living with a mental illness.

The Minister for Community Services, Jenny Macklin, yesterday announced a $1.4 million funding injection to Perth Home Care Services.

The group provides intensive, one-on-one support to people in Wheatbelt communities so they do not have to travel to Perth for treatment.

Ms Macklin says the support will help people cope with the problems associated with mental illness.

“It can be all sorts of practical help,” she said.

“It might be help finding suitable housing, it might be improving relationships with family and friends, helping people with practical skills, which might include holding down a job if people are able to do that.

She says the funding injection will ensure the vital service continues.

“One of the very important services is dealing with the terrible social isolation that often comes with mental illness, so these are very important services that will now be able to continue to be provided,” she said.

Questions about ‘delay’ in reporting ship’s grounding

Australian maritime authorities are disputing a claim that a coal ship grounding off central Queensland was reported within five minutes.

The Shen Neng 1 ran aground on Douglas Shoal just after 5pm (AEST) last Saturday afternoon.

In a statement today the Chinese state-owned Shenzhen Energy Transport apologised for the incident saying it is cooperating with authorities.

The company says it alerted Australian authorities about five minutes after the ship ran aground but the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) disputes the claim, saying it was not told for about an-hour-and-a-half.

It then took another 25 minutes for Maritime Safety Queensland to become involved.

AMSA has asked the Chinese company to “clarify” it’s comments.

There was criticism last year that authorities took too long to act after a major oil spill off south-east Queensland.

Salvage operation

Meanwhile, authorities are starting to pump oil from the stricken coal carrier.

They are putting safety equipment in place to reduce the risk of a further spill as they prepare to pump out the remaining fuel.

About 250 workers are on standby should any oil reach the coast.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) general manager Patrick Quirk says it could take days to transfer all the oil.

“This is just a part of a long process and we need to keep our eye on the short game, which is the pumping of the oil,” he said.

“The medium-term game is the refloating and what we’re going to do when we refloat her.”

Mr Quirk says the carrier is holding together.

“The salvors have put on electronic monitoring, hull-monitoring equipment and they have advised that they are detecting no further deflections of the hull, which means that the damage has stabilised,” he said.

“We’re doing a metre-by-metre check of the ship with the salvors and that’ll determine what goes into the computer programs in terms of the damage assessment reports.”

Mr Quirk says the weather conditions today are favourable.

“A bit of a wind change due Monday which we’ll need to keep our eye on, but at the moment we’re not being alarmed by the weather change,” he said.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says the oil transfer is a difficult and delicate operation.

“Anyone who thinks this is all over, red rover frankly, they’re not getting it right,” he said.

“This is going to take a lot of time, a lot of technical precision and hard work and it’s a very difficult situation still with no absolute guarantee of success.”

Political ‘sightseeing’

Meanwhile, Queensland Opposition Leader John-Paul Langbroek has criticised Premier Anna Bligh for travelling to inspect the stricken coal carrier.

Ms Bligh will today fly over the ship.

Mr Langbroek say Ms Bligh is the fourth Labor politician to go and look at the damage.

“I think it’s interesting that Anna Bligh is following the example of Kevin Rudd, [Federal Environment Minister] Peter Garrett and [Queensland Transport Minister] Rachel Nolan to be the fourth senior politician to take a plane flight over the Shen Neng 1,” he said.

“I think it’s time for the sightseeing to stop by senior politicians and let’s just let the experts get on with fixing it.”

- Reporting by Paul Robinson, Maria Hatzakis, Kerrin Binnie and Natalie Poyhonen

Opposition calls for release of hospital performance data

The State Opposition is accusing Premier John Brumby of secretly withholding damaging information on Victoria’s health system.

Mr Brumby has released his own plan for an overhaul of national health policy, which he says is better than the the Federal Government’s proposed takeover.

But opposition health spokesman, David Davis, has slammed Mr Brumby’s calls for transparency.

He is questioning why the State Government has not released any hospital performance data for the second half of last year.

“Where are those figures and why is Mr Brumby so slow to release them,” he asked.

“With the exception of South Australia, that’s had an election, Victoria’s the only state that’s failed to release the figures for the first half of the financial year across the country.”

Federal police asked to probe coal ship oil spill

Australian Federal Police (AFP) have been called in to investigate how a bulk coal ship ran aground on the Great Barrier Reef off central Queensland.

Salvage crews are today expected to start pumping fuel oil off the Shen Neng 1, which ploughed at full speed into Douglas Shoal, east of Rockhampton, last Saturday.

The Chinese-registered ship ruptured a fuel tank and damaged the engine room when it ran aground.

Several tonnes of fuel oil leaked into the ocean but that has been dispersed with chemicals.

About 975 tonnes of oil remain on the stranded ship.

Two response boats are at the site and have inflated booms around the coal carrier to minimise any further spillage.

Around 250 people are on standby in case oil reaches the coast but that is now considered unlikely.

The AFP has been asked to consider mounting a criminal investigation into how the ship ran aground but has not yet confirmed whether it will investigate.

Maritime authorities are already looking into the incident.

Salvage begins

Authorities will today start pumping the remaining oil supply off the ship ahead of attempts to refloat the vessel.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) spokesman Patrick Quirk says recovery ships are in place to prepare for the pumping operation.

“The bunker barge Larcom and our salvage response vessels managing the boom are in position,” he said.

“The processes are taking place to get the oil moving but as yet they are not pumping any oil.

“It is an involved process to connect the pumps and the hoses and our check lists satisfied.

“We’ll start the process when we’re happy that it’s safe to do so.”

Premier Anna Bligh will also fly over the stricken ship today.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, Federal Environment Minister Peter Garrett, Greens Leader Bob Brown and Queensland Transport Minister Rachel Nolan have already flown over Douglas Shoal this week.

It is still not clear when authorities will try to move the ship off the reef.

RSPCA spokesman Michael Beatty says it is looking for volunteers to head to central Queensland should there be a major oil spill.

Mr Beatty says it is only a contingency plan.

“Particularly wildlife carers or people who have experience with wildlife is to go on to our website and register on there – obviously with contact numbers, details of experience and availability – and then we can mobilise those people basically instantly to go up and assist if needed,” he said.

Meanwhile, a maritime law expert doubts the Queensland Government will recover the full cost of salvaging the ship.

The State Government says the ship’s owners will be forced to pay for the full clean-up and salvage costs.

But maritime expert Professor Nick Gaskell has told AM that there is a cap on the amount they will have to pay and there is likely to be a gap between the actual cost and what the owners will have to pay.

“There is a maximum amount calculated according to the size of the ship, and my calculations on the information available to me indicate that the maximum sum for this ship will be in the region of $23.5 million,” he said.

“In exchange for having a no-fault liability, the ship owners are entitled to have a ceiling, a maximum amount of damages for which they’re liable.”

Roxon dismisses Brumby’s health plan

The Federal Government says it cannot agree to some of Victoria’s demands for changes to the Commonweath’s health plan.

Victorian Premier John Brumby wants a 50-50 funding split without any changes to the GST revenue.

He says the current offer is not good enough.

“There is no new money in this for Victoria. There is no new money in their so called 60-40 proposition,” he said.

But Federal Health Minister Nicola Roxon says Treasury modelling shows the Victorian plan would cost the Commonwealth an extra $150 billion over the next decade, assuming it also took full funding responsibility for primary health.

“We don’t think Premier Brumby’s funding request is realistic,” she said.

The Federal Government’s health and hospitals plan takes a leaf out of Victoria’s book by setting up local health networks and shifting to activity-based funding, paying the efficient price of every public hospital service to public patients.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd is continuing his hospital visits, distributing millions for cancer services and spruiking his plan.

Behind the scenes, the Federal Government talks as if it has health reform in the bag. Publicly, the Prime Minister is keeping up the tough talk.

“As Prime Minister I was elected with a mandate to deliver better health and hospital services for all Australians and I would just urge John [Brumby] to work with the Australian Government because state governments cannot afford to fund this system for the future,” he said.

“The Australian Government must be the dominant funder for the future.”

State and territory leaders are due to meet in a week-and-a-half to decide whether to support the Federal Government’s proposal.

Ms Roxon will travel to Tasmania this morning to explain the plan to the caretaker Premier, David Bartlett and the leader of the Tasmanian Greens.

Garrett to inspect oil spill ship site

Federal Environment Minister Peter Garrett will check the status of the bulk coal ship stranded on the Great Barrier Reef off central Queensland with a flight over the area this morning.

Three ships are expected to arrive today to help transfer the remaining 950 tonnes of oil aboard the Shen Neng 1, which hit Douglas Shoal at full speed east of Rockhampton on Saturday.

The Chinese-registered ship ruptured a fuel tank when it ran aground, spilling more than two tonnes of oil into the ocean, but that has been dispersed with chemicals.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, Greens Leader Bob Brown and Queensland Transport Minister Rachel Nolan have already flown over Douglas Shoal this week.

Authorities say they are well prepared for any leakage when they remove fuel oil from the stricken ship. Booms will be used to contain any spills.

The incident has prompted debate over shipping channels, pilotage and monitoring systems.

The Queensland Government says it has also made preparations on land in case of a spill which could not be contained.

Queensland Transport spokesman Dave Stewart says the risk of fuel leaking from the ship during the process is very low.

“I can say the preparedness – if oil does leave the ship and does move to the beach – is high,” he said.

However, it is expected to be weeks before the ship can be towed off the reef.

‘Ticking time bomb’

The director of the Australian Marine Conservation Society, Darren Kindleysides, says the risk of pollution to the reef will be reduced once the oil is removed.

“As long as the oil stays on the coal carrier it’s like a ticking time-bomb,” he said.

“In terms of reducing the risk to the reef, getting the oil off that vessel as quickly as possible is certainly the way to go.”

However, Mr Kindleysides says that will not be the end of it.

“You’ve still got a ship there grounded, you’re still damaging the habitats in the area and of course you’ve still got all the coal on board,” he said.

But Queensland Resources Council chief executive Michael Roche says the oil is a bigger environmental concern than the coal on board.

“I think the real fear from these sort of events are from the liquid fuels that power the ships rather than the cargo they’re carrying,” he said.

“I think people with other agendas, anti-coal agendas, are focusing on the fact that this particular ship’s cargo is coal.

“The threat to the reef is not the coal, it’s from the oil that all ships carry.”

Reef damage

Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (GBRMPA) chairman Russell Reichelt says it is likely the coal carrier has caused significant damage to coral.

Mr Reichelt says the ship is essentially excavating the reef and divers will investigate once it is safe.

“The kinds of things our divers will look for will be the anti-fouling paints and anything that might be toxic that’s scraped off the vessel and sitting on the seabed and that’s not uncommon in ship groundings,” he said.

“So we expect there to be some clean-up operations needed after the ship’s removed.”

Authorities prepare to salvage oil spill ship

The Australian Maritime Safety Authority (ASMA) has sent a ship to help minimise an oil spill from a bulk coal carrier that ran aground on the Great Barrier Reef off central Queensland.

The Chinese coal carrier, Shen Neng 1, hit Douglas Shoal at full speed east of Rockhampton at the weekend.

Coral shredded the port side of the ship, breaching the engine room and rupturing a fuel tank.

Authorities say several tonnes of oil leaked from the ship but has since been dispersed with chemicals.

The ship is laden with more than 60,000 tonnes of coal and almost 1,000 tonnes of fuel oil.

Today’s salvage operation will involve removing the remainder of the ship’s oil.

Authorities say it is unlikely the stricken ship will break up.

Tugboats are being used to stabilise the ship and maritime authorities will decide today when to remove the oil, which must go before any attempt is made to move the vessel.

Salvage crews are working on a plan to get the carrier off the shoal without causing too much more damage.

Dutch-based company Svitzer is handling the salvage operation and has flown in three planeloads of specialist equipment, including heavy duty pumps and compressors.

‘Risky exercise’

Officials hope the fuel transfer will begin either this afternoon or tomorrow while the weather is good, but Queensland Premier Anna Bligh has warned it will be a complex and risky exercise.

Ms Bligh says it could be one of the most difficult salvage operations in Australia’s history.

“We have to prepare for the possibility that more oil may well escape,” she said.

“That means that we have in cooperation with the councils along this shoreline a comprehensive civilian response should we have any further oil come out of the vessel and on to any of the shores.”

Removing the oil from the stricken carrier, however, is only the first part of the problem.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) spokesman Patrick Quirk says salvage experts are still considering what to do with the coal on board.

“They’re going through the ship from the bow to the stern seeing what’s damaged, seeing what’s leaking” he said.

“They’ll run that through their calculations. That’ll give them the structural strength of the vessel.

“That’ll allow us to know when she’s floating the stresses and strains on that ship and whether we need to take out cargo to ensure her safety.”

Coastline preparations

MSQ spokesman Mark Strong says the Pacific Responder tug will arrive this morning to help contain any spills during the salvage operation.

“The salvage crews will be attempting to remove the fuel oil from the vessel weather permitting,” he said.

“The decision then will be made about what else needs to be done to salvage the vessel.

“The Pacific Responder will help deploy booms to contain any oil that may spill during any transfer or salvage operation.”

Mr Strong says many of the problems expected soon after the incident have not eventuated.

“As things have turned out, things have gone well – the vessel is stabilised, there’s no further oil escaping,” he said.

“That doesn’t mean we don’t need to take all of the precautions you would when the vessel’s in such a sensitive environmental area, but so far things have been going well.”

A local disaster management group has been briefed this morning on what to do if oil from the ship reaches the coast.

Rockhampton Mayor Brad Carter says the meeting is discussed precautionary measures.

“To make sure that if there is that remote chance of oil coming ashore, that we have everything in place to plan for that eventuality, should that occur,” he said.

Councillor Carter says he is relieved after having a first-hand look at the stranded coal ship.

He flew over the area yesterday and says there is no sign of an oil spill and the waters are very clean.

“One very pleasing thing was very close to the ship this very large turtle had come up out of the water – to see that there was fish life available in and around the ship – it was pleasing to see that,” he said.

“I did expect to see evidence of oil floating on the water but there was none.”

‘Better option’

However, maritime law expert at the University of Queensland, Professor Nick Gaskell, says refloating would be a better option because it is notoriously difficult to transfer cargoes like coal.

He also says the longer the ship is grounded, the greater the risk of it breaking up and polluting the pristine waters.

But Professor Gaskell says people can have confidence that the salvage experts will do everything they can to stop that happening.

“The salvors are on a no-cure, no-pay contract normally,” he said.

“That means if they fail to save the ship, they get nothing.

“They could work for four or five weeks, incur huge expenditure and get nothing.

“If they do succeed, then they will be given a reward based on the value of the property, the ship and the cargo and so on.

“So it’s very much in their interest to make sure that this ship gets off intact.”

Professor Gaskell says the state and federal governments need to oversee the salvage operation to ensure commercial interests do not come before the environment.

But he says the governments need to leave the highly technical issues to the experts and continue to resist media and political pressure to act hastily.

Investigation

Mr Quirk says investigations into the incident have been stepped up.

“Navigating a ship through this channel should not be rocket science. Any competent crew should be able to do it,” he said.

Authorities have boarded the Shen Neng 1 to interview the crew.

Environmentalists say it could take decades for coral under the stricken ship to recover.

Maritime authorities say the ship has moved between 20 and 30 metres since it ran aground.

World Wildlife Fund spokeswoman Gilly Llewellyn says a coral dust plume has formed in the water.

“To build up the structures – the kind of the fragile branching, the kind of the dome-shaped corals – that intricate architecture that makes a coral reef a teeming haven for life, that literally could take decades to build,” she said.

“We’ve got what you could call almost a ticking environmental time bomb in the form of 900 tonnes of heavy fuel in the fuel tanks of that ship.

“If it were to break apart, that would be a massive environmental catastrophe.”

Pilot calls

Meanwhile, a marine pilot contractor says companies running coal carriers through the Great Barrier Reef are becoming more aware of the routes their ships take.

There have been calls for better pilotage since the Shen Neng 1 ran aground.

It is not compulsory to use a pilot in the area.

Australian Reef Pilots chairman Don McLay says about one in four coal ships travelling through the Great Barrier Reef carry a pilot and about half of those do it voluntarily.

Mr McLay says there is a growing awareness about navigating troublespots.

“About three years ago when we visited clients, shippers, ship owners and charterers overseas, none of them had any risk management focus to any great extent,” he said.

“But now when we visit them, the person we meet is the risk manager and he’s particularly interested in the behaviour of their vessel through these areas.”

No shortcut

Yesterday, authorities said the coal ship was not taking a shortcut through the Great Barrier Reef when it ran aground.

AMSA said the crew lodged a shipping plan outlining its intention to take the route between Douglas Shoal and the Capricorn group of islands to the south.

There is a six-nautical-mile gap between the two but it is within the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park’s designated shipping area.

Questions have been raised about why the ship did not travel further north before turning.

MSQ said the ship was not on a preferred route but it is not illegal to travel through it.

Investigators are still looking into why the ship veered off course far enough to hit the shoal.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd flew over the affected area with AMSA officials on Tuesday morning.

Mr Rudd said yesterday those responsible must be brought to account.

But Federal Opposition Leader Tony Abbott yesterday accused Mr Rudd of watching the oil spill but not acting to fix the problem.

Mr Abbott said the Prime Minister’s assurances were not good enough.

“We have a Prime Minister who is no good at making things happen,” he said.

Federal matter

Ms Bligh says she would like to see electronic monitoring of ships extend further down the Queensland coast. But she says extending the coverage area is a Federal Government matter.

“These are Commonwealth waters, and while the state cooperates with the Commonwealth on its northern monitoring program, ultimately the decision is one for the Commonwealth Government,” she said.

“I’m very pleased the Prime Minister inspected the area … and I would hope we’ll get a very receptive ear in Canberra on this issue.”

Authorities say a preliminary report on the grounding of the coal carrier could take several weeks.

- Reporting by Nicole Butler, Kerrin Binnie, Emma Pollard and Chris Logan

Health plan doesn’t address aged care: Greens

The Greens say states should not sign up to the Commonwealth’s health plan until they know what is on offer for the aged care sector.

State leaders are due to meet Prime Minister Kevin Rudd in Canberra within a fortnight to decide whether to support the Federal Government’s proposal.

But Greens Senator Rachel Siewert says there is still a lot of detail missing.

“We are facing an aged-care crisis in Australia,” she said.

“Until those issues are resolved, I think the states would be silly to sign up to something when they don’t know the complete picture.

“We’ve got shortages in beds now. That is only going to worsen into the future if we don’t make significant reform to aged care.

“That isn’t yet on the table in the negotiations with the states.”

Reef oil spill an outrage: Rudd

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says it is outrageous that a Chinese coal carrier was far enough off course to slam into part of the Great Barrier Reef at the weekend.

This morning Mr Rudd flew over the coal carrier Shen Neng 1, which ran aground off Douglas Shoal, east of Rockhampton, rupturing a fuel tank and spilling oil into the ocean.

Tug boats are being used to stabilise the ship and authorities say the oil must be removed before any attempt is made to move the vessel.

Mr Rudd flew over the affected area with officials from the Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) and says those responsible must be brought to account.

“It is outrageous that any vessel could find itself 12 kilometres off course in the Great Barrier Reef,” he said.

Mr Rudd says he takes threats to the Reef extremely seriously.

“From my point of view as Prime Minister of Australia, there is no greater natural asset for Australia than the Great Barrier Reef,” he said.

“I take any threat to the Great Barrier Reef fundamentally seriously.

“The practical challenge is to deal with this situation now. The practical challenge then is to bring to account those who are responsible,” he said.

The ship has leaked about two tonnes of oil and maritime authorities are trying to stop more seepage.

Authorities say chemical dispersants have broken up the spill and it is unlikely the ship will break up.

Reef shortcut

Officials have also raised the possibility the carrier was taking a shortcut through the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park.

Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) general manager Patrick Quirk says he believes reports from fishermen that ships regularly take shortcuts.

“I do not doubt what the fishermen are telling us. We have thousands and thousands of vessel movements on the Queensland coast every year,” he said.

“All I’m saying is that some vessels may not always utilise best practice. We are not always aware of those occasions.”

The Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (GBRMPA) says ships have been caught and prosecuted in the past for taking shortcuts through the reef.

But GBRMPA chairman Russell Reichelt says he does not know of any major incidents like this in the past.

“The incidents have tended to be very sporadic and occasional,” he said.

“Every year or few years, a small amount of oil will be spilled from a vessel and similarly ships go off course and run aground on the reef, but in my experience they’re very rare,” he said.

He says he is not aware of ships taking shortcuts through the Douglas Shoal area.

“There have been detections of ships further south that have appeared to be taking shortcuts in areas where they wouldn’t be permitted,” he said.

“Those ships are investigated and prosecuted, but that particular area, no.”

Mr Quirk says the ship’s crew has yet to be interviewed.

“The crew are on board and that formal investigation will get underway as soon as it’s safe to do so.”

Earlier, Greens Leader Bob Brown inspected the ship before accusing bulk carriers of using the pristine waters of the Reef as a “coal highway”.

He said authorities were turning a blind eye to the problem.

“Nothing has been done about it by the authorities,” he said.

“I will be busying myself today to establish where the Australian Federal Police are in their enquires about how this disastrous situation has arisen.”

Senator Brown also called for a complete review about the number and size of ships moving through the Great Barrier Reef.

International legal experts say the Chinese coal carrier may face a number of infringements, but the Federal Government is limited to the action it can take to regulate shipping lanes.

Concern politics driving national population strategy

A Queensland conservationist says it should not take the new Federal Population Minister a year to develop a national population strategy.

Federal Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry Minister Tony Burke was appointed Australia’s first Population Minister at the weekend.

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says a strategy for managing the nation’s population growth will be created over the next 12 months.

Queensland Conservation Council spokesman Simon Baltais says the appointment of a Federal Population Minister is long overdue.

Mr Baltais says the population strategy should be created sooner because Australia’s high growth rate is one of the most important national issues.

“Twelve months is just a little bit too long,” he said.

“There’s plenty of information from the CSIRO that’s been collected over the years – I don’t think he needs to wait that long.”

He says while he welcomes Mr Burke’s appointment, he is concerned it was driven by politics.

“I think this is where some of the scepticism starts to creep in and that is is this just to deal with the politics of it,” he said.

“Is this just about trying to smooth waters over and get them over the next election or is this a genuine desire to fix the problem?

“There’s plenty of research around – they know what they need to do, they know where the problems are and I would hope they would come up with something a lot sooner than 12 months.”

Liberal leader to be briefed on health and hospital plans

The Health Minister Nicola Roxon says the Federal Government will do its best to brief the Liberal leader Will Hodgman on the proposed shake-up of the health system.

The government is threatening to begin the process for a referendum on the changes if no agreement can be struck with the States at a meeting within a fortnight.

Mr Hodgman could become Tasmania’s next premier on Wednesday when Labor attempts to give up power.

Ms Roxon says she wants to make sure the Liberal leader’s properly briefed about the health proposal as early as possible.

“To assess the interest of the Tasmanian population in signing up to this deal and the Prime Minister and I will both be meeting with him at a time that is suitable to him,” Ms Roxon said.

‘Fundamental disagreement’ remains over health plan

Victorian Premier, John Brumby, says he still ‘fundamentally disagrees’ with the Federal Government’s push to overhaul hospital funding.

Mr Brumby met with the Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd, in Melbourne today, to thrash out differences on the Commonwealth’s proposed reforms.

Mr Rudd wants to to be responsible for 60 per cent of hospital funding, while Mr Brumby is pushing for state-based funding pools.

The Premier says there will be more negotiations.

“We’ve got COAG on April 19th, so we’re not drawing the line yet, and we will continue to have discussions,” he said.

“We spend about 28 per cent of our budget on health so we wouldn’t lightly make a decision to change those arrangements in the future. We’d want to know they’re right.”

Mr Brumby continues to maintain he only wants what is best for patients.

“We’ve got some pretty fundamental disagreements on that at this stage, and our view is that the most important thing for people in Victoria is more money in the hospital system today,” he said.

The Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd says there is still a long way to go in negotiations with the premiers, and it will take some time.

“We’ve identified, both yesterday and today, areas where I think we can strike agreement and those areas which we continue to have disagreement,” he said.

“Narrowing the list is part of what negotiations are about.”

Health shake-up shouldn’t thwart hospital upgrade: Roxon

Federal Health Minister Nicola Roxon says negotiations over the Commonwealth’s health plan should not affect Bendigo Hospital’s redevelopment.

The Victorian Opposition previously raised concerns that the redevelopment’s next stage could be delayed because of uncertainty over the proposed new funding model.

The State Government has provided $55 million for the initial planning stage of the project, but is yet to commit further money.

Ms Roxon says state governments should not delay decisions because of the planned overhaul.

“I think that any state government making those decisions will be making a mistake to defer things while these discussions are underway,” she said.

“Those planning decisions should still be made.

“The offer we have on the table actually provides more resources to help fund planned infrastructure projects.”

Palmview housing plan gets $11.5m boost

The Sunshine Coast Regional Council has secured Commonwealth funding for a new housing development.

The Federal Government allocated $50 million for eight affordable housing projects, with the Sunshine Coast council getting $11.5 million for the Palmview residential development.

Councillor Anna Grosskreutz says the funding is proof of the importance of working cooperatively with the other levels of government.

“I travelled to Brisbane to meet with the federal Minister one day to personally deliver a plea and a letter from my housing task force,” she said.

“I also went to see Minister Hinchliffe and the coordinator-general with a personal letter as well in support of our application, so I think if you are willing to do the hard yards and work cooperatively you can deliver some results.

The Palmview project has received the biggest share of eight affordable housing projects across Australia.

“It’s great for the Sunshine Coast. People have long lamented the fact that we weren’t being supported by state and federal governments and this is proof that if we can work cooperatively with these governments we can receive such a large amount of funding for infrastructure,” Cr Grosskreutz said.

Bligh wants ‘certainty’ from Commonwealth on future population

Queensland Premier Anna Bligh says the states need more certainty from the Commonwealth about future population to plan for infrastructure.

She says it is hard for the states to plan for growth when they do not know how many people to expect.

Ms Bligh says a national population policy would help.

“Giving states and local government more certainty about the sort of numbers we could expect to be catering for,” she said.

She says the Commonwealth should also have a federal infrastructure plan.

“It would be a very powerful tool for national prosperity, good planning and certainty for other levels of government,” she said.

A two-day summit will start on Tuesday morning in Brisbane to discuss the pressures facing south-east Queensland.

Opposition Leader John-Paul Langbroek says it is just the latest in a series of forums hosted by the State Government.

“So far we’ve seen an obesity summit, a 20-20 summit, a reef summit,” he said.

“The Premier loves having summits and then moving on to the next target.”

Unionist seeks preselection despite PM’s rejection

A Tasmanian unionist is planning to run for the Senate, despite being rejected by the Prime Minister at the last federal election.

Kevin Harkins of the Electrical Trades Union withdrew as Labor’s candidate for the lower house seat of Franklin, amid accusations of heavy-handed union tactics.

The Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd, said at the time there was “Buckley’s chance” of Mr Harkins becoming a Labor Senator, calling him a “pugilist”.

Mr Harkins is now seeking Senate pre-selection, but will not say whether he has received Mr Rudd’s blessing.

“I think those words were nothing more than a misunderstanding, and they should be placed into that basket,” he said.

“I think we’ve all moved on since those things happened.

“Maybe it was a mistaken identity, or something like that. I don’t really know. You would have to ask the Prime Minister about that.”

A spokesman for the Prime Minister says Mr Rudd has been open about his personal views but pre-selection is a matter for the Tasmanian ALP.

The party’s State Secretary, John Dowling, has declined to be interviewed.