Doomadgee inquest finishes hearing legal submissions

The inquest into death in custody of Cameron Doomadgee has finished hearing legal submissions in Brisbane after being told a finding of the use of deliberate force is not possible within the constraints of the law.

Mr Doomadgee died from a ruptured liver and portal vein after a fall at the police station on Palm Island off Townsville in north Queensland in 2004.

Senior Sergeant Chris Hurley was acquitted of Mr Doomadgee’s manslaughter in 2007.

At issue in the latest inquiry into his death, is whether the injuries were caused accidentally in a fall with Senior Sergeant Hurley, or whether they resulted from deliberate force.

The family of Mr Doomadgee has urged the coroner to rule that his injuries were caused by deliberate force.

The family’s submission argues Senior Sergeant Hurley maintained he fell to the side of Mr Doomadgee, until the medical evidence made it clear that his account could not explain the injuries.

Counsel for Senior Sergeant Hurley is urging the coroner to find the injuries were caused accidentally and his initial recollection of the events was faulty.

But Counsel for the Queensland Attorney-General says the medical evidence suggests the injuries could not have been caused by a simple fall.

Counsel assisting the coroner, Ralph Devlin, told the court the dichotomy between the deliberate and accidental application of force was irreconcilable.

He said circumstantial evidence points to deliberate use of force by Sergeant Hurley but medical evidence leaves open the possibility the fatal injuries were caused accidentally.

Deputy Chief Magistrate Brian Hine says he hopes to hand down his findings in Townsville on May 14.

Doomadgee inquest to hear submissions

The inquest into the 2004 death in custody of Cameron Doomadgee in the Palm Island watch-house, off Townsville in north Queensland, will hear submissions in Brisbane today.

Mr Doomadgee, 36, died from massive internal injuries after being arrested by Senior Sergeant Chris Hurley in 2004.

An inquest into Mr Doomadgee’s death found Senior Sergeant Hurley caused the fatal injuries.

But in 2007, a jury found him not guilty of Mr Doomadgee’s manslaughter.

Senior Sergeant Hurley appealed against the original findings and a new inquest opened in north Queensland last month.

Deputy chief magistrate Brian Hine will hear oral submissions in Brisbane today before making his decision

Police Commissioner defends officers over death in custody

Queensland Police Commissioner Bob Atkinson says there is no evidence that officers acted inappropriately with regard to a recent death in custody case.

A 41-year-old man was found dead in his cell at the Rockhampton watch-house in central Queensland on Tuesday.

It was the fourth death in custody in a month.

Commissioner Atkinson says the coroner is investigating, but he believes protocols are being followed.

“100,000 people taken into custody each year and we endeavour to provide the best possible care and treatment,” he said.

“But it’s just unavoidable that there’s a degree of risk associated with people who in many cases are quite vulnerable.”

Coroner probes death in custody

Victoria Police and the coroner are investigating the death in custody of a 41-year-old man on Monday night.

The man was arrested in Richmond in relation to six armed robberies committed in the area.

He was treated in hospital for wounds sustained during his arrest and after a psychiatric assessment was deemed unfit for questioning because of his mental state.

He was the taken to the Melbourne Assessment Prison where he was placed under suicide watch after being assessed as “high-risk”.

Correctional Services officers found him dead in a shower cell.

A Department of Justice spokeswoman says an independent report will be prepared for the coroner by the Office of Correctional Services Review.

Peter Norden, a former prison chaplain and activist on prisoner rights issues says one third of all prisoners in Victoria have been assessed as having a mental health problem at some point in their life.

“The issue is are we using our prisons to deal with people who have got severe and chronic mental health problems,” he told ABC Radio’s Jon Faine.

“The prisons now are becoming, if you like, the new asylums.”

Call for Royal Commission into deaths in custody

A prisoner rights group is calling for a Royal Commission after the fourth death in custody in Queensland in the past month.

Police say a 41-year-old man was found unconscious in his cell at the Rockhampton watchhouse early Tuesday morning.

Ambulance officers were alerted when he could not be revived.

In recent weeks, a 27-year-old man and a teenager have died in the Arthur Gorrie Correctional Centre in Brisbane, and a 42-year-old man died at the Wolston Prison.

Debbie Kilroy from the group Sisters Inside says a Royal Commission is needed.

“It seems like the deaths in custody are on the increase and that’s a very concerning situation we have in Queensland,” she said.

The Police ethical standards command and Crime and Misconduct Commission (CMC) are investigating.

A report will be prepared for the coroner.

Coroner to probe death in custody

A 39 year-old prisoner has died in Sir Charles Gairdiner Hospital after his family made the decision to switch off his life support.

Earlier this month Grantley Ross Winmar was taken from Acacia Prison to the hospital for surgery for a suspected bleed on the brain.

The Department of Corrective Services says Mr Winmar had a history of medical illness.

A coronial inquiry will be held into the death in custody.

Mr Winmar’s family has been offered counselling.

Prisoner found dead in cell

The Arthur Gorrie Correctional Centre in Brisbane’s south-west is in lockdown after a 27-year-old prisoner on remand for rape was found dead in his cell.

A Corrective Service’s spokesman says the man’s death does not appear to be suspicious.

It is the third death in custody in Queensland in the last month.

Another prisoner was found dead in a cell at Brisbane’s Wolston Prison on Tuesday.

The 42-year-old was serving a six-year sentence for child sex offences and had been in jail for 11 months.

Corrective Services said there were no suspicious circumstances in that case either.

The death has been referred to the coroner and to the chief inspector of prisons.

Last week, protesters gathered outside Parliament House in Brisbane to accuse prison authorities of failing to help a seriously ill Indigenous teenager who died while on remand for stealing a car.

Sheldon Currie, 18, was found on his face in his cell by an inmate at the Arthur Gorrie Correctional Centre.

He spent four days in intensive care at Princess Alexandra hospital before dying on February 20.

Death in custody concerns

Police are being urged to release information about the death of a 33 year old man in the Perth watch house at the weekend.

The diabetic man was arrested on Saturday night and placed in a cell at the watch house.

He was twice discharged from hospital in the hours before his death but police say it is too early to say whether incorrect medical advice is to blame.

The hospital has released a statement saying staff would co-operate with the coronial inquiry into the death.

Marc Newhouse from the Deaths in Custody Watch Committee says he has been trying to obtain information about the death.

“Based on the information that we have so far, there’s some things that don’t match up, that don’t make sense.”

“It’s possible that something went wrong, something went amiss, that will be the subject of a coronial inquiry but we’ll be watching very carefully in the meantime.”

It has been ten years since the last death at the watch house.

Police have rejected suggestions that the committee has been denied access to information about the death.

Police say the Internal Affairs Unit received no request for information from the Deaths in Custody Committee.

Police say the family of the dead man and their legal representatives have been kept fully informed about the progress of the internal investigation.

Officers are preparing a report on the circumstances of his death for the State Coroner.

Hurley offers ‘sympathy’ to Doomadgee family

The policeman acquitted of a 2004 death-in-custody on Palm Island in north Queensland has, for the first time, offered his sympathy to the victim’s family.

Senior Sergeant Chris Hurley has been giving evidence at the latest inquest into the death of Cameron Doomadgee.

The 36-year-old Palm Island man died from internal injuries suffered during his arrest for allegedly being drunk and a public nuisance.

Sergeant Hurley told the hearing that he offered his “sincere sympathy” to Mr Doomadgee’s partner and family.

He said he was “sorry for the angst they’ve had to suffer” in recent years.

But under questioning from the Doomadgee family’s barrister, Sergeant Hurley said he “didn’t regret his actions on the day” and that he had arrested people for the “same type of offence” since then.

Outside court, family spokeswoman Elizabeth Clay said the apology did not mean anything.

She said the family needs to forgive to move on but cannot do so yet.

The inquest has finished its public sitting with submissions to be accepted from legal counsel over the coming weeks.

Jail accused of neglecting Indigenous inmates

Racial tensions are running high in Queensland after the death in custody of an Aboriginal man.

Sheldon Currie, an 18-year-old remand prisoner, died last month and this week there have been claims he was denied adequate medical attention at a privately run Brisbane jail.

But Queensland’s Corrective Services says there was medical intervention: that he was fully assessed and treated on three consecutive days.

Indigenous community members are calling for a full inquiry into the teenager’s death.

They say they have more examples of medical neglect and racial hatred within Queensland’s prisons.

Prison chaplain Reverend Alex Gator is among those suspicious of the circumstances surrounding the teenager’s death.

She says it is normal practice for her to be called to seriously ill inmates but no-one called her to Sheldon Currie’s hospital bed.

Then after the 18-year-old died, the reverend says a prison official told her not to cause trouble when she went to the jail to conduct a memorial service.

“I did not like his tone of voice, and in no uncertain terms he more or less said to me not to stir up the boys,” she said.

“I said, ‘I’m here to provide spiritual support to people … they are grieving, these young boys. They have lost a brother.’”

Reverend Gator says another prison worker told her he was quitting after Sheldon Currie’s death.

“He said ‘I’m leaving, I’ve had enough. I’m not happy at what had happened here,’” she said.

Racial hatred

Reverend Gator has been a prison chaplain for 19 years and she says Indigenous inmates are regularly treated badly. She says she believes it is a matter of racial hatred.

“There was a young Murri boy up at Borallen. He was sick this young boy, doubled up in pain,” she said.

“He was told there was nothing wrong with him.”

“They finally took him to the Princess Alexandra Hospital. The specialists said, ‘if you’d waited another day, you would have died.’ He had appendicitis and it would have burst.

“There’s another mate there at the Wolston Correctional Centre. He’s got serious health problems; he’s in a wheelchair. He fell out of his wheelchair and he was on the floor unconscious.

“He don’t know how long he was unconscious, and what he said to me was ‘Aunty Alex, they do not care, they don’t give a damn.’”

Panadol cure-all

Debbie Kilroy from the prisoner advocacy group Sisters Inside agrees the medical care given to Indigenous inmates is woeful and unacceptable.

“Medical treatment is, as women would inform me, ad hoc,” she said.

“The answer to every treatment – every ailment – is a Panadol.

“So it doesn’t matter what your illness is, you will get a Panadol. If you’ve had your arm cut off in the industry you’ll get a Panadol.”

Ms Kilroy says the only way prisoners will get adequate care is if they are treated outside the jails.

Saturday AM has not been able to get a response to the claims about inadequate medical care in Queensland prisons.

Corrective Services says Queensland Health is in charge of the medical services.

Queensland Health says the Arthur Gorrie facility where Sheldon Currie was imprisoned is privately run, and the department declined to comment on broader issues.

Inquest told of Palm Island ‘scuffle’

The coronial inquest into the death in custody of a Palm Island man will continue hearing evidence today from the police officer acquitted of his manslaughter.

Cameron Doomadgee died from massive internal injuries in the Palm Island police watch house in 2004.

Senior Sergeant Chris Hurley was acquitted of manslaughter in 2007.

He started giving evidence in Townsville yesterday with the focus on a fall involving him and Mr Doomadgee at the entrance of the police station.

Sergeant Hurley said he was not sure what caused the incident but he did not think that he landed on Mr Doomadgee and denied striking or speaking to him in an abusive way.

He told the reopened inquest that Mr Doomadgee punched him in the face when he tried to escort him from the police vehicle to the station, and they had scuffled.

He denied that he was angry with Mr Doomadgee and told the hearing that he could not hear the prisoner call out from his cell – and that if he did he would have gone to him

Sergeant Hurley is expected to continue giving evidence until this afternoon.

Teen was ‘refused medical help’ before death in custody

Queensland’s Indigenous community will march on State Parliament today, enraged over the circumstances surrounding a recent death in custody.

An 18-year-old prisoner died late last month and there are claims Brisbane jail staff denied him adequate medical treatment even though he was too sick to walk.

Today’s march coincides with the reopened inquest into the controversial Palm Island death in custody.

Prison chaplain Reverend Alex Gator says inmates at the Arthur Gorrie correctional centre called her with news of the latest tragedy last month.

“This young youth, only 18 years of age, he had spent five weeks on remand and then the five weeks he was at Arthur Gorrie he became ill, so he was ill for six days,” she said.

“The first time he’d gone to the medical centre he was given Panadol, other times he’d gone he was told that there was nothing wrong with him. So he was repeatedly denied medical assistance.

“Towards the end the boys had to carry him, the Murri boys in his unit had to carry him, because he could hardly walk.

“They nearly caused a riot, the Murri boys. They yelled out to the officer, ‘get him to the hospital’ because something was wrong with him.

“And one officer made the comment, ‘Well if he can go to the toilet, there’s nothing wrong with him’.”

Reverend Gator says the teenager was ultimately rushed to hospital and put on life support. But he died a few days later on February 20.

“I conducted a memorial service. The boys said they only saw him a couple of weeks ago talking, laughing, joking and next thing they hear this young man is dead,” she said.

Reverend Gator says the teenager should never have been put in jail because he had a serious pre-existing medical condition.

“That is the question we’re asking – why? Why was he in prison, not in hospital? I mean he wasn’t a terrorist, a paedophile, rapist or a murderer,” she said.

“He was in there for a misdemeanour. And as far as I’m concerned, it’s just racial discrimination towards Aboriginal people. This is about racial hatred attitudes towards Aboriginal people.

“They’re deliberately turned away and told there’s nothing wrong with them. And Corrective Services have failed in their duty of care to provide a service to this young man.”

‘Could have been avoided’

Brisbane Indigenous community leader Sam Watson says news of the death in custody has spread like wildfire.

“We are very concerned about this because this appears to be yet another Aboriginal death in custody that could have been avoided, that should have been avoided,” he said.

Queensland Corrective Services has issued a written statement saying “there are no suspicious causes” in the teenager’s death.

The statement adds that all deaths in custody are referred to the coroner and to the chief inspector of prisons for investigation.

But Mr Watson says the Indigenous community is calling on the Queensland Government to instigate a full coronial inquest.

“There have to be a lot of questions answered. We want to get to the bottom of this and we want to do it very, very quickly,” he said.

“We don’t want this to drag on like Palm Island. The Palm Island death in custody happened six years ago. Here we are six years down the track; we still haven’t received any outcomes, we still haven’t received any real closure.”

No one has been convicted over Cameron Doomadgee’s death on Palm Island in 2004 and the circumstances surrounding his death remain shrouded in doubt.

This week the third coronial inquest into the watch house death is being heard and today Senior Sergeant Chris Hurley is expected to take the stand.

The initial inquiry found the policeman fatally wounded Mr Doomadgee but Senior Sergeant Hurley was later acquitted of manslaughter charges.

Doomadgee inquest hears more evidence

The reopened inquest into the death in custody of a Palm Island man in north Queensland in 2004 continues today.

Cameron Doomadgee was found dead in the local watch-house after being arrested by Senior Sergeant Chris Hurley.

The original inquest into his death ruled the policeman caused the fatal injuries and he was tried and acquitted on charges of manslaughter and assault.

A review in the District Court ruled the original inquest findings should be set aside and the inquest reopened.

A witness whose evidence was pivotal in the original inquest will be re-examined today.

Giving evidence at the new inquest yesterday, Palm island man Roy Bramwell told the court he saw Sergeant Hurley punching as well as kneeing Mr Doomadgee inside the police station.

Mr Bramwell will continue his evidence this morning.

Blasphemy accused Christian man dies in Pak jail, police claims ‘suicide’

Lahore, Sep. 16 (ANI): A Christian man who was held on blasphemy charges is reported to have committed suicide in a Pakistani prison, while human rights activists are smelling foul play in his death.

Masih, 25, was arrested on Friday after hundreds of protesters accused him of desecrating the holy Quran and attacked a Catholic church in the Sambrial district near the Indian border

“Masih, being accused of blasphemy, was put in a separate cell where he committed suicide by using a string,” the Daily Times quoted Sialkot District Jail Superintendent Farooq Lodhi, as saying.

Punjab Minister for Minority Affairs Kamran Michael said the police had not handled the case properly.

“I have seen the body and there were torture marks on it,” he said.

Meanwhile, Masih’s family has claimed that he was tortured to death by the jail staff.

According to a news channel report, local Christians had snatched his body from the police and shifted it to a private hospital for an autopsy.

Human Rights Commission of Pakistan Chairwoman Asma Jahangir has demanded registration of a murder case against police officials concerned.

“This is death in custody and the police authorities are responsible,” said. (ANI)